And I would like to point out that I feel uncomfortable having Minsc in my party. I cannot remember enough of Ajantis and Kivan to make a judgement there. I will however say that there is a differenc… (View Post)

You are making a logical mistake there. Evil implies harming, oppressing, and killing A therefore B From this, you cannot conclude that from B follows A. In the context given, that is largely a super… (View Post)

No one spoke of pacifism. The description says "respect for life", not "inability to harm any life". The narrow path of "Good" in DnD is about having the player pretend … (View Post)

@Chronicler Unfortunately that is not true as far as D&D is concerned. A serial killer is evil, even if she is not acting out of self-interest. Murder is evil. By the (2nd edition) rule books, do… (View Post)

@DreadKhan In breaking the siege I was mostly frustrated that after I had killed a few of the enemies, allies started pouring onto the battlefield and stealing my kills. I reloaded the battle several… (View Post)