Fun is more important to gameplay than a rigid adherence to PnP. Realistically a lot of people just don't want to castrate their protagonist by restricting themselves like that, so I'd agree with the… (View Post)

We could steal a feature from 3rd Edition and have dexterity give a bonus to daggers/short swords, instead of strength. That would be effective. (View Post)

I think if a thief could beat a fighter in a fair fight, there'd be no point in the fighter class. Assuming they're at equal levels, anyway. The fighter would have better THAC0, weapons (assuming the… (View Post)

Could you stop spamming the forum with these threads and simply make one mega-thread? (View Post)

I don't see how letting us know her kit (assuming she has one) and what her strengths are would be a spoiler. Imoen is a vital NPC in BG2 and you describe her as "A neutral good (iirc) theif/mag… (View Post)