It's one thing for a good-aligned character to occasionally steal, for example. It's quite a different thing for a supposedly good-aligned character to be a fan of Shar. I think the problem here is t… (View Post)

I know, but she should have died a glorious death as a warrior hero, standing strong against Thay to the end. I was already so very angry at how they killed off the Blackstaff (my #1 beloved FR NPC),… (View Post)

As I've noted before, I'm a huge FR novels fan. I own and and have read almost all of the FR novels. And absolutely, yes, the 2e and 3e novels are the best. The novels that came after the Spellplague… (View Post)

But this completely misses what @Kamigoroshi and I are saying. Whether or not a game uses a "non-European" setting is a separate issue. Within the Forgotten Realms, you have many areas that… (View Post)

Okay I get what you're trying to say here, but I personally don't buy this argument. If WotC were to say to the cRPG gaming world "Come to us with your idea for a D&D game and we will give i… (View Post)