You can't keep a bad man down

Well, this was a bit of a shock. Not only do I have to deal with trash like Ogre Mages and such but ... Bhodi and Irenicus both came back? Into my pocket plane no less? I thought I had seen the last of those losers! Grrrr!
Well, at least these were the weakest versions of themselves.
Well, at least these were the weakest versions of themselves.

-1
Comments
The only "shocking" part ... have you never played a non-evil protagonist through this part of the game? The challenge throws one set of enemies at you if you're evil, and another if you're good or neutral. The next pocket plane challenge (unlocked after beating Yaga-Shura) also has a good/evil split, though that one's based on dialogue choices.
Also, looking at it, it's a combined alignment/reputation check. If your protagonist is non-evil with a reputation of 8 or higher, you fight various evil foes culminating in Bodhi, Irenicus, and Sarevok. If your protagonist is evil or has a reputation lower than 8, you fight various good and neutral foes culminating in Eltan, Aran, and Ellesime.
So, you're saying that your "true neutral" protagonists have always decreased their reputation with two or more of slayer transformations and obviously evil companions (Dorn, Hexxat, Viconia). Face it, you're an evil player.
.....The real hit to our reputation ... we dropped to "despised" ... came about totally by accident. I had given Edwin the Chain Contingency spell, and he stuck 3 Horrid Wilting spells in it. It was set to trigger as soon as any enemy was sighted. I think you can see the problem with that set-up. I had not considered that there might be non-hostile civilians in the AOE. Sure enough, there were a number of civilians around ... four if I recall ... who were promptly vaporized. We took such a hit to our reputation that we didn't have enough money at the time to remedy the siuation. (I had just dropped 40 grand on stuff at the magic shop, and another 20 to have Caspenar upgrade some of our gear).
.....Needless to say, I have since rectified that situation.
I'm not evil! I'm just drawn that way.