Skip to content

When Barding

Do you sing or do you kill?

Comments

  • zur312zur312 Member Posts: 1,366
    definitly kill everything
    unless jester
  • FubbyFubby Member Posts: 189
    Sidequestion

    What is better? Fightercleric or Paladin?
  • zur312zur312 Member Posts: 1,366
    i would say STOP THIS RIGHT NOW OR ELSE!! R$ Vt4h43urth2uic3hurid

    joking

    fighter/cleric is really hardcore buffed tank bg1 and bg2

    paladins bg1 are kind of weaker fighters no spells(only inquisitor can cast his) black guard is really good maybe stronger than fighters

    paladins bg2 are great especially cavalier who works like fighter/cleric with swords
  • FubbyFubby Member Posts: 189
    So in Bg1 Fighter cleric in bg2 paladin?
  • zur312zur312 Member Posts: 1,366
    i would say definitly fighter/cleric in bg1
    in bg2 both are great so power level doesn't really matter
  • FubbyFubby Member Posts: 189
    Ok Cool. Thanks
  • FrozenDervishFrozenDervish Member Posts: 295
    edited July 2013
    Kill cause singing while great takes away a party slot.

    Fighter/Cleric trumps paladin in both games.

    The advantage to being a paladin is the innate immunities they recieve with their various kits such as level drain immunity as well as their single class level progression which lets them level slightly faster than a multi. They also have access to more weapons and the holy avenger.

    The disadvantage of the paladin is that their spells come very late and at 1/4th the efficiency and are capped at 3rd or 4th level spells.
  • zur312zur312 Member Posts: 1,366
    edited July 2013
    f/c is better better because multiclass are better than single but
    paladin even with level 1-4 spells is so damn powerfull that it doesn't really matter that cleric is higher in this tier

    how powerfull is cavalier? normal ascension mod tob final solo that much powerfull
  • KamigoroshiKamigoroshi Member Posts: 5,870
    The bard character should really focus on fighting. It's better for you, as the player, to be in charge of the singing. This way of barding is infinitive times more fun and immersive to boot. Not to mention the stress relieving factor of it. For sound deaf players I recommend sticking to humming instead. Wouldn't want some neighbour summoning the Flaming Fist on you for disturbing their peaceful beer o'clock time, right?
  • the_spyderthe_spyder Member Posts: 5,018
    I am trying to figure out how you are fighting OR singing as a piece of leather or metal strapped to the side of a horse.????
  • FubbyFubby Member Posts: 189

    I am trying to figure out how you are fighting OR singing as a piece of leather or metal strapped to the side of a horse.????

    I could give you the highly detailed scientific explanation, but for now:

    -d(a(du/dx))/dx+(d^2(b*(du^2/dx^2)/dx^2))+co*u+c1*(du/dt)+c2*(du^2/dt^2)=f(x,t)

    this is tough to type in without an equation editor, (du/dx) denotes the partial derivative of u with respect to x, (du^2/dt^2) denotes the second partial derivative of u with respect to t, etc.
    anyways, this is a model equation from my finite element analysis class
    When b=0, c2=0, co=0, c1=rho*A, a=kA
    this equation represents unsteady heat transfer in a fin

    When a=0, b=E*I, co=k, c1=0, c2=rho*A
    this equation represents transverse vibrations in a beam

    When a=E*A, b=0, c1=0, c2=rho*A, co=0
    it represents longitudinal motion(vibration or wave propogation) of a slender rod
  • BelgarathMTHBelgarathMTH Member Posts: 5,653
    I think this is an interesting, fun question, although not everyone posting is actually answering the question.

    My bard characters sing instead of fight. I guess that puts me in the minority. I actually find it interesting to play in the game though. Because the song benefits have a very short range, I have to stay right behind my front line fighters, which necessitates constant positioning of my avatar.

    I can't just marquee select everybody in the party and click target to attack when I'm playing a bard (I always take skald.) When an enemy is sighted, I usually separate myself out a bit to the side, so I can get a marquee select that includes everybody in the party except me, order them to attack, and then, when my front line fighters rush forward toward the enemy, I rush in right behind them. I try to position myself close to the front line fighters, but far back enough to keep my song effects on the back line.

    Then I can start ordering spells cast if needed for whatever battle. (Some battles I hold the whole party back and let the mages throw AoE's first.)

    As soon as I can find and learn the Invisibility spell, I stay invisible for pretty much the rest of the game. I find it kind of funny and satisfying to roleplay a ghostly voice coming out of nowhere, demoralizing and scaring enemies half to death if they don't figure it out. (My party is in on the trick, of course.) It goes kind of like this, in my head:

    Me: (invisibly, singing, playing lute) "Kill, kill, kill, kill, the stupid ogre. Bonuses, bonuses, bonuses, bonuses to your hit rolls and damage."

    Ogre: "Arrrgh! Where is tinkly music sound and screechy human sing-song coming from? Hurts my head! Make it stop!" (Drops club and puts hands over ears.)

    Fighter: "Eat steel, monster!" (splortch)
  • rathlordrathlord Member Posts: 171
    Dropped by just to say that I got what @the_spyder was saying and I'm pretty confident no one else did. Barding is horse armor. Carry on.
  • the_spyderthe_spyder Member Posts: 5,018
    Yes. @rathlord hit the nail on the head.
  • ZanathKariashiZanathKariashi Member Posts: 2,869
    edited July 2013
    Bards are a support character. They do whatever is needed at the time. Due to shoddy implementation of Bard song, a vanilla bard should never be singing ( personally find even the jester song an utter waste of time until 15+, and since the invisibility-song exploit is complete and utter cheese, even directly contradicting the description of the ability itself, I refuse to use it), as they contribute much more shooting arrows or darts, or buffed up, can even melee reasonably well.

    The Skald is ironic....in BG they're the only bard worth spending time singing rather then fighting...but in PnP the Skald is the only bard who can sing WHILE engaging in melee combat (and are the 2nd strongest melee bard kit after the Gallant).
  • The user and all related content has been deleted.
Sign In or Register to comment.