Skip to content

Anyone else play Magic: The Gathering or any other nerd-related IRL physical hobby?

sandmanCCLsandmanCCL Member Posts: 1,389
I recently got into both Warhammer 40k and got back into Magic: the Gathering. Hanging out at the hobby store eats up all my free time now, and I'm glad for it.

Anyone else? If so, what do you play as? I've got some fairly obnoxious decks but the serious collectors still kick my butt come tourny time.

Comments

  • ShinShin Member Posts: 2,344
    Long time player of both 40K and Fantasy Battle, as well as Blood Bowl and various other board games. Also did some live-action role playing for a few years.
  • ARKdeEREHARKdeEREH Member Posts: 531
    I've played MTG since 1997. Most of my decks are focused around surviving and winning in passive ways without actually attacking people. My favorite deck is mono white and is focused around life gaining. If anyone tries to attack me or target me with any spells they will instead cause me to gain life. I usually play in free-for-all group games of 3-5 people, so in the beginning everyone is hesitant to attack first because they don't want to be seen as the threat that everyone should attack. This gives me the time to build up my defenses and get my combos in place so that whenever anyone plays a creature or something I will benefit from it.

    I have another deck that is red/white and follows a similar model, but it uses the transcendence/sulfuric vortex combo so that I can survive if I have less than zero life, but everyone else slowly dies. I also use worship, platinum angel, and form of the dragon as alternatives if the transcendence combo fails.

    I also have a black/blue deck that focuses on killing people's creatures and countering their spells. It's also defensive to a point, but unlike the others relies on offense to actually win. I kill people's creatures whenever they try to attack me and then once there's a large number of creatures in graveyards I seize control of all of them and kill my opponents with their own creatures. If that fails, I have a combo with Phage the Untouchable that usually works.
  • sandmanCCLsandmanCCL Member Posts: 1,389
    Phage the Untouchable is an awful card. I am totally serious. 4/4 deathtouch, makes player lose the game if she hits, for 7CMC? Not worth it, especially because there are ways a lot of decks can manipulate her "If she wasn't played from your hand, lose the game" downside. If you've got 7 mana out, there are a lot better cards to play that will more directly make you win a match and are a lot harder to remove from play. She's a good side-board card against a life gain deck only.

    Currently I'm trying to run an Azorius deck. Tons of creatures with detain, lots of ways to bounce them back to my hand to detain again, and my damage comes by way of Invisible Stalker roided up with enchantments. I managed to handily beat someone who had about 16 total creatures in play despite the fact I literally only ever had 2 even touch the board.
  • ajwzajwz Member Posts: 4,122
    edited November 2012
    I play wfb and 40k. I used to play mtg to a very high level, but stopped after I left uni, which coincided roughly to when the rules changes kicked in
  • jhart1018jhart1018 Member Posts: 909
    I enjoy M:TG but if I'm going to play in a tourney, I like sealed deck. That tends to even the playing field a bit.
  • LadyEibhilinRhettLadyEibhilinRhett Member Posts: 1,078
    Nerd-relatied IRL physical hobby?
    I play Quidditch. Does that count?
  • WigglesWiggles Member Posts: 571
    Board games like Kingsburg and Lords of Waterdeep, D&D 3.5e (will look into D&D Next), host LAN parties that feature Borderlands 1&2 on PS3, Halo 4 when it's released, BG:EE when it's released, Starcraft, UT99, Minecraft, HoMM3. Nerdgasams for me on my weekends. XD
  • sandmanCCLsandmanCCL Member Posts: 1,389
    @Wiggles The hobby store near me does a lot of those types of board games. Apparently their income is pretty even across the board, between M:TG, Warhammer and board games. I haven't really tried any of them because when I'm down there, I'm usually engaged in one of the other things but some of what I see people playing looks really fun. Lots of strategy, right?

    @ajwz: I'm gonna blame it on me just waking up, but wfb? Not ringing a bell. That an acronym for Warhammer Fantasy?
  • Avenger_teambgAvenger_teambg Member, Developer Posts: 5,862
    This one is fun: http://www.elementsthegame.com/ just because you mentioned MtG.
  • WigglesWiggles Member Posts: 571
    Both of those are strategy games ya. I like LoD because it's all strategy. No dice rolling.
  • ajwzajwz Member Posts: 4,122

    @Wiggles The hobby store near me does a lot of those types of board games. Apparently their income is pretty even across the board, between M:TG, Warhammer and board games. I haven't really tried any of them because when I'm down there, I'm usually engaged in one of the other things but some of what I see people playing looks really fun. Lots of strategy, right?

    @ajwz: I'm gonna blame it on me just waking up, but wfb? Not ringing a bell. That an acronym for Warhammer Fantasy?

    yep, warhammer fantasy battle.
  • ARKdeEREHARKdeEREH Member Posts: 531

    Phage the Untouchable is an awful card. I am totally serious. 4/4 deathtouch, makes player lose the game if she hits, for 7CMC? Not worth it, especially because there are ways a lot of decks can manipulate her "If she wasn't played from your hand, lose the game" downside. If you've got 7 mana out, there are a lot better cards to play that will more directly make you win a match and are a lot harder to remove from play. She's a good side-board card against a life gain deck only.

    Currently I'm trying to run an Azorius deck. Tons of creatures with detain, lots of ways to bounce them back to my hand to detain again, and my damage comes by way of Invisible Stalker roided up with enchantments. I managed to handily beat someone who had about 16 total creatures in play despite the fact I literally only ever had 2 even touch the board.

    My combo with Phage is that while Phage is in my graveyard I imprint her onto Dimir Doppleganger, which is already in play. Since Phage is merely imprinted on Dimir Doppleganger, she never actually came into play. Therefore, I don't lose the game due to her not coming into play from my hand. Since Dimir Doppleganger was already in play it doesn't have summoning sickness, so I can then attack someone that turn and they don't have time to prepare to stop it. If by some chance they have any creatures in play I have plenty of other cards that will either kill, tap, or return their creatures to their hands. I usually also have a counter spell on Isacron Scepter and more in my hand, so if they try to do anything to Phage or prevent the damage, I can prevent that as well.

    What is "detain?" I'm guessing that's an ability in one of the newer editions. It's been a while since I've seen newer cards, so I'm not familiar with all of their abilities. Your strategy with Invisible Stalker sounds similar to what one of my friends does with a creature called Rabid Wombat. His whole deck is based around putting enchantments on the Rapid Wombat, which then becomes more powerful for each enchantment cast on it. His creature generally can't be targeted by opponents, can block any number of creatures, and has very high attack and HP.
  • sandmanCCLsandmanCCL Member Posts: 1,389
    edited November 2012
    @ARKdeEREH

    image
    I run a ton of these. I only have one, but I've got a card called Detention Sphere which is basically the same thing for the same CMC (it just takes 1(W)(U) instead of 2(W)) which exiles that card and every card with the same name.

    Also, example of my detain shenanigans:
    image
    image

    All your creatures sort of sit around twiddling their thumbs forever.

    It's extremely rare I don't make it to that amount of mana. Seriously, the only things that are proving to be a problem for me right now are if I get swarmed before I get a chance to play a creature, or I get a terrible hand.

    Also, your combo there is pretty easy to shut down with unsummons. I am running a whole bunch of these right now, too.
    image
  • DrugarDrugar Member Posts: 1,566
    edited November 2012
    I've got three Warhammer Fantasy armies, all works in progress.
    Number one is a 2500 point Skaven army, mostly unpainted (240 infantry units can take a while). Took it over from a friend who quit because he didn't feel like doing all the work. The infantry is going bit by bit but occasionally I take a break by finishing a larger model like my Warp Lightning Cannon.
    Then I've got a 2000 pt Warriors of Chaos army ( no group shot, alas), which is 90% done (only marauders need work), most proud of my Tzeentch Warriors.

    Then I've assembled about 1500-2000ish points of Daemons of Chaos though I haven't formed those into a coherent army yet. They're just models I collected because they looked cool and it recently occurred to me that it's enough to build an army of (30 bloodletters, 20 Horrors, Skulltaker, 3 Bloodcrushers, 3 Flamers, Herald of Khorne and Tzeentch, Daemon Prince).
    They're on the painting list after I finish the Skaven.

    Aside from Warhammer, I DM two D&D games, I've played Star Wars D&D, Shadowrun and Call of Cthulhu.
  • MedullaOblongataMedullaOblongata Member Posts: 434
    I occasionally play M:tG, but only casually. I enjoy a small variety of tabletop rpg's:
    D&D 2.0 - 4.0 + D&D Next (I don't partake in version wars)
    Classic Spycraft (Anxious for 3.0!)
    White Wolf
    Shadowrun
    Star Wars d20
    Kobolds Ate My Baby

    Also other fun games:
    Betrayal at House on the Hill
    Any Choose Your Own Adventure books
    Dungeon Quest
    D&D Board Games
    Illuminati
    Scotland Yard
    Munchkin
    Settlers of Catan
    Zombies!!!

    Guys, I don't know if this game is very well known, or if it's actually mainstream:
    Browbeat my fiance into doing the dishes for once

    LOL I can't do the dishes because I have dyshidrosis (sp?) :P
  • LadyRhianLadyRhian Member Posts: 14,694
    More than I can count. Top Secret, Black Tower, Talisman, Stuperpowers (You get stupid superpowers, like Body Odor Forcefield or, I kid you not "Ballistic Spooge", which you must then use to fight crime. One game online involved the Bagel Ninja (turn baked goods into weapons) and Rude (B.O. Forcefield, "Flatulence of Life") fighting a Galactic Janitor who wanted to cleanse the earth... of humans). And in addition to other card games like Munchkin, Munchkin Fu, Battle of the Bands, Lunch Money, I played Magic the Gathering through Revised and 4th edition. I got into it somewhere around the time "The Dark" expansion came out, though you could still find cards from "Legends" occasionally. I had a white deck with a card called Cleanse, which destroyed all Black Creatures in play. It got too expensive for me to continue after Alliances, and I gave it up to concentrate on playing AD&D and Vampire: The Masquerade, selling my decks and cards to purchase modules and sourcebooks and boxed sets. I had 4 Serra Angels, 4 Seraphs from Ice Age... 2 Veteran Bodyguards... Ah well. Just got too expensive. Much too expensive. Oh, I also have the Munchkin RPG and the Star Munchkin expansion.
  • sandmanCCLsandmanCCL Member Posts: 1,389
    edited November 2012
    @LadyRhian: Not surprised you like munchkin! You strike me as the type of person who is endlessly amused at clever wordplay.

    And it's also kind of funny to me the specific cards you mentioned. Nowadays, those cards are kind of meh. Serra Angel, while still good, was downgraded from a rare to simple uncommon about 6 years ago. She rarely sees competitive play anymore because for 5 mana, you could play something like this instead:

    Angelic Overseer
    Herald of War

    And these are just things with the same converted mana cost. There's actually bigger things for less, especially if you start delving into multi-colored cards.

    I hadn't played with any seriousness since like 1998 so it was a big learning curve for me, too, finding out all my favorite old strategies were totally awful in today's game.



    I've also been watching and analyzing different groups of nerd. At the hobby shop I hang out at all the time now, you have all sorts of folks who come in but I've noticed there's a different attitude that seems to accompany each type. Even among the different CCGs, you see people who are markedly different between one game and another.

    M:TG guys tend to be a little more serious and less socially awkward than a lot of the other guys. Yu-Gi-Oh players? Those guys are weird. I don't know what it is. But like. I dunno! I don't mean this in a bad way. They are just different. Kind of otaku-level geek. It's probably the anime show tie-in. Then you have the Warhammer guys, and they are... manlier? than the other crowd. I suppose it's the level of do-it-yourself-ness that comes with the hobby. You've got current and former military dudes playing it at least at my store, and there's actually a 60ish-year-old guy that plays it with his 35-year-old son and 13-year-old grandson.

    It's all pretty cool, if you ask me.
  • LadyRhianLadyRhian Member Posts: 14,694
    edited November 2012
    That leads me to an amusing anecdote from my gaming past. Back in the early to middle 80's, I got the chance to attend a gaming con taking place at West Point, in New York. I played a lot of D&D and AD&D there, but I also got a chance to play this game called Merc, where you play Mercenaries in the modern day (Mercenaries were tremendously big/popular back then. Even fairly mainstream bookstores would carry Soldier of Forturne Magazine and whatnot. Anyhow, even through I was a geeky teen, I was into "Men's Adventure" books like Mack Bolan, Able Team and Phoenix Force. So I jumped at a chance to play the game. Well, everyone else there was male, and there were also four West Point Cadets playing in that Tournament Game, complete with the DA haircuts and everything. They looked at me like I had two heads when I sat down to join the game. I will give you three guesses as to who survived that game, and who didn't (and the first two don't count).

    I still have the folder and character sheet from that game in my gaming possessions. I asked if I could have it after the game, and the GM said yes. :) I also like to think those Cadets learned a valuable lesson about judging books by their covers.
    Post edited by LadyRhian on
  • ajwzajwz Member Posts: 4,122
    @sandmanCCL
    Haha, where I used to play mtg in London, half of the room was dedicated to yu-gi-oh players and half to mtg players. It was really funny seeing mtg player looking down on yu-gi-oh players and thinking "thats nerdy" :p
  • sandmanCCLsandmanCCL Member Posts: 1,389
    @ajwz I know, right? It's comical. I'm of the mind to embrace all geekiness wherever it lies, and to encourage other people to find happiness wherever it might lie.

    There's two guys I know of who play both M:TG and YuGiOh down there. One is one of the owners, so he obviously doesn't let people turn-nose at anyone else's hobby in the store. Other one is a guy who's always dressed head to toe in either Philadelphia Eagles gear or Utah Jazz swag, so he's clearly a sports geek on top of a card geek.

    Just hanging out at the hobby place reminds me of my favorite customers back when I worked at GameStop. I guess I just love nerdy, awkward people. Reminds me of myself before I learned how to be loquacious and a smooth talker, I guess.

    This really all has nothing to do with anything. Just typing. Hasn't really been a lot to talk about here on the forums that hasn't already been beaten to death multiple times so sue me for gabbing for the sake of gab.
  • rexregrexreg Member Posts: 292
    i played MTG Revised thru 8th ed. or so...as LadyRhian stated, it's just too d&^$ed expensive to keep up w/ all the new cards; i kept a couple of decks, but got rid of just about all of my MTG cards...
    Squad Leader, a WW2 tactical level board game that is more a simulation than a game
    Munchkin rocks
    Dominion, although i play much less frequently than i used to
    i started playing D&D out of the pink box & still play, although my current group has turned up their noses @ 4th ed.
    also played a gi-normous number of other RPG's--Top Secret, Gamma World of varying editions, Star Frontiers (yuck), Traveller, various super-hero games, GURPS, Twilight 2000, Star Wars Saga & on & on...
    also lots of Uno & Weed...both card games pretty much mindlessly entertaining...
    also a die-hard Steelers fan
  • sandmanCCLsandmanCCL Member Posts: 1,389
    rexreg said:


    also a die-hard Steelers fan

    BEST FRIEND <3

    Dude I tell you what, I'm stressed as hell about Roethlisburger's injury. Apparently he cracked a rib and it's hovering over his aorta. If he got hit again before it healed, it could puncture his <i>heart and kill him. So, the timetable on him returning needs to be guestimated long-side rather than short side of the recovery.
  • rexregrexreg Member Posts: 292
    @sandmanCCL
    yeah...just as the Steelers were gelling on both sides of the ball
    Roethlisberger seems to play through injury each season, but this can't be played through
    at least Leftwich & Batch, who both have issues, have seen significant playing time...

    i miss Bettis
  • DrugarDrugar Member Posts: 1,566
    So a while ago I probed amongst my D&D group and it turned out, only one of them had played Baldur's Gate (for a whole three hours, ten years ago).
    Since we needed a new D&D game anyway (The last one got a chaotic infighting party eventually), I suggested that I'd start a campaign based on Baldur's Gate, a thought that'd been in my head for a while. Loosely based, of course, the linearity of the computer game doesn't translate well to PnP roleplaying, but generally on the course.

    I made a trailer for a character creation afternoon a while ago; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vm7wgC8CcIs

    What came out was;
    One human Barbarian, we're ruling he's not a 'from the savage land' barbarian but just an undisciplined, emotion driven fighter with a temper issue. He's originally from Mulhorand and living with foster parents, his real parents dissappeared shortly after he was dropped off in Candlekeep. He assumes that his continued stay in Candlekeep has something to do with the mysteeerious tattoos all over his body. He'll go with the group because his foster father wants to use Gorion's 'expidition' as a way to get someone outside the walls of Candlekeep to look into the Iron Crisis. (I needed a better hook than the flimsy one the game provides)
    One Aasimar Cleric of Lathander, about to embark on a self-imposed journey to gather as much influence as possible to rid the world of evil forever. Other than that, the player hasn't given me much to work with, so I'm going to have to make shit up as it comes along.
    One Half Elf Sorceress and (unbeknownst to her) a Bhaalspawn. Unsure of her new powers, she will try to develop them in a way that allows her to protect the ones she cares about, like her foster father Gorion. (heehee). We're going with the Pathfinder sorcerer class so she'll have a specific bloodline, which the player has graciously allowed me to pick for her (since it'll make for more effective roleplaying if she doesn't know where her power comes from). It was most excellent.

    And lastly

    One Human Dread Necromancer, bhaalspawn #2. To prevent the story from revolving around 1 player only, I included a second Bhaalspawn (and with classes like Sorcerer and Dread Necromancer, I basicly had to). His mother will accompany Gorion and the others on their flight out of Candlekeep where she will defend her child with her life.

    Baldur's Gate is fairly player-centric of course, so with four players (and thus four people demanding prime attention) I've made sure to include enough plot for all of them to stay hooked (or so I'm planning).
    The first portion of the game will mostly revolve around the two Bhaalspawn, while I'm seeding the first hooks for the Barbarian and Cleric. Around the BG2 area, I'll flip attention to them, involving the Cleric in the Amaunator questlines (Unseeing Eye and Shade Lord, roughly) and having Irenicus mostly interested in the Barbarian's tattoos, unraveling his past in the meantime.
    The Throne of Bhaal portion (which'll take 2-3 years to get to probably) will go balls-to-the-walls, with massive levels and massive combats in a startling finale (which won't be like the ToB portion at all, because that'd be fairly boring to play, but I have time to figure that out).

    Anyway, figured some of you might be interested in hearing about it, if anyone has any particular ideas on what things to include or look out for (one Speak with Dead spell can ruin a lot of BG's plot, for example), feel free to pitch in (*cough @LadyRhian becauseyou'rehardcoreatDMing cough*).
    For example, I've been planning to include some NPC's as cameo's or questgivers. A friend of mine (and veteran DM) suggested that I should keep the Khalid and Jaheira/Xzar and Montaron conflict alive, making both groups possible questgivers and allowing the players to decide which side to pick.
    Edwin and Minsc are of course obvious questgivers, and so on.

    Anyway, just sharing.
    I'm going to write up locations, a timeline and possible quests in those locations. Then I need to think of what to put in a new trailer for the upcoming session. Huzzah!
  • CyhortCyhort Member Posts: 78
    I've wanted to get into a tabletop RPG on and off for a while, my boyfriend too. The two biggest problems are our total lack of friends close by, not much free time and my god awful math "skills". I did play a game of Pokemon cards once. I think. <_<
  • eltonbarreleltonbarrel Member Posts: 262
    i play mtg some years ago.
    now study chess
    play ad&d for 15 years. 2013 16 years!
    munchkin
    great dalmuti
    wintertales ( a very funny italian game, based on a battle between winter and spring. players tell stories and should create a link to other story players tell. based on simply rules, at the end of the game you put all stories together to create a tale. )
    bang!

  • LordOfLostSocksLordOfLostSocks Member Posts: 23
    I play D&D with a group of 7 people or so. I also play other various tabletop games.
  • agrisagris Member Posts: 581
    Playing Hackmaster 4e with a solid group of 5 (think a mix of 1st/2nd ed. AD&D. Lots and lots of non combat skills), and the occasional game of Munchkin.
Sign In or Register to comment.