What FR novels should I read to find out more about religion/faith in FR?
johntyl
Member Posts: 400
I wish to know more about the religious faith in BG such as Helm/Torm/Lathandar etc. Are there any Forgotten Realm novels that touch majorly on that? Thanks in advance!
0
Comments
Although it may be both faster and more informative if you read sourcebooks instead of novels. Faiths & Avatars would be a good start.
Besides, the Avatar series give a lot of insights on gods and how they work and interact with the world. Not exactly about how faith is organised, but still a must-read to understand the role of the gods (and the events depicted in Baldur's Gate, too)
Avatar series - Mystra, Cyric and Kelemvor
Cleric Quintet - Deneir
Moonshae trilogy and Druidhome trilogy - druidic faith
Empryean Odyssey trilogy - Tyr and Helm
Finder's Stone trilogy - Finder
Haunted Lands trilogy - Bane
Lady Penitent trilogy - Llolth and Eilistraee
Lost Gods trilogy - Bane, Bhaal and Moander
Priests series - various
Twilight War trilogy - Lathander, Mask, and Shar
War of the Spider Queen series - Llolth
However, I disagree about Lady Penitent (btw, OP, I suggest you to read Starlights and Shadows and War of the Spider Queen before Lady Penitent). That series had some serious issues with its representation of the drow gods (mostly of Eilistraee and her followers, who were warped in those books and were not what they are meant to be in their lore and previous representations of them--both their principles and their rituals are misrepresented in Smedman's books (but there are mistakes for Vhaeraun as well). It also was the result of an editorial mandate to adjust the drow and their gods to WotC's plan for 4e FR/D&D: the author herself disagreed with the changes that the novels were supposed to bring. They surely made the drow poorer and far less interesting. Aside from that, nearly everything in it has been reverted through the mass resurrection that the Sundering brought, and some of it wholly ignored, as if it had never happened or been written (so the series has little to no impact to how things turned out).
WotSQ and LP, in all honesty, entirely missed Eilistraee's point, what the redemption she wishes for the drow actually is, and the kind of positive goddess she is. If you want to see what Eilistraee is actually about, read Starlights and Shadows by Elaine Cunningham. Eilistraee gently and lovingly leads to drow to open their hearts to life, to see all the beauty that they were denied, and sets their dreams alight once more. Through this goddess, they re-learn to live anew, that's Eilistraee's "redemption". I think Elaine made a splendid work at showing that in her books, in all those little scenes where Eilistraee ever so gently is there in so many important moments of Liriel's travel, and helps her to see life in a deeply different way.
In short, Eilistraee is supposed to be about sparking enthusiasm and passion for all that wonderful there's in the world. She has always been about helping the drow forge their own path in life, and about acceptance of everyone for what they are. She's surrounded by evil and took so many blows, yet she can still find the beauty in everything, even in what was broken or in the darkest souls (like her people have become), and gives all herself make it flourish again in all she touches. She's among the very few who can see that spark of light within the drow, and basically the only one who--even when all others consider them monsters--never stops trying to open their eyes to what they're missing on in life, to make her “children” *live* once more.
However, in the WotSQ (books 4 and 5, which have been written by Smedman and Athans, who--coincidentally--also wrote and edited LP)+LP books made Eilistraee *all/mostly* about killing Lolth, rather than doing all she can to help the drow who were lost or in need (and there were many during that time), which is very reductive for this goddess's character. I'm not saying that Eilistraee wouldn't get rid of Lolth, but that wouldn't be her #1 goal, nor her preferred way of action, precisely because there needs to be understanding in the drow, and the choice needs to come from them. Killing Lolth isn't going to magically change the drow into her followers. If Lolth died, most drow would look for demonic patrons, rather than becoming good, the added bloodbath due to the factions struggling for power would only be a further blow to this goddess.
Furthermore, in those books (and only in those books) her followers are militaristic, misandrist, self-righteous a**holes, nothing like they're supposed to be in this goddess' lore (I mean, they mutilate males for watching their dances--which is flat out evil--when in canon males too can dance...). In addition to that, all of sudden, after millennia of dedicating herself to that cause--to *all* drow--redemption goes from being a positive change, from rediscovering life, to redeeming yourself and renouncing to what you were born as (which is antithetical to all that Eilistraee stands for, and has never had anything to do with her, it was never even considered by her, in over 10k+ years that the drow have been cursed, and in over 20+ years of lore about her); and at the end of those books it is assumed that the vast majority of drow are all of sudden unredeemable and to be cast down a priori, for no reason at all... glad that this was undone, honestly.