92 Roll F/M/C
Build crafting idea.
You roll a 92, but you can only place points in descending order 18, 17, 16, 15, etc. No double or triple 18s.
How would you allocate those scores with a fighter/mage/cleric?
Or any other class for that matter. It'd be interesting to hear reasons for different point spreads
You roll a 92, but you can only place points in descending order 18, 17, 16, 15, etc. No double or triple 18s.
How would you allocate those scores with a fighter/mage/cleric?
Or any other class for that matter. It'd be interesting to hear reasons for different point spreads
0
Comments
For the F/M/C I would say 18 Intelligence, 17 Wisdom, 16 Dexterity, 15 Constitution, 14 Charisma, 12 Strength. Or I might flip the Wisdom and Dexterity.
I assume this for the full Bhaalspawn saga. Of all the scores, Strength is the easiest to just keep boosted ALL the time (between potions, Gauntlets and Girdles). Intelligence maybe doesn't need the 18, but it will help with learning spells from the start. Wisdom provides bonus Priest spells and the Dexterity helps with armor class and missile "to hit" bonus.
The lower Charisma does mean you'll pay a cost penalty at the start, but ultimately money is not in short supply.
I would mention, I am categorically NOT a power gamer. I don't particularly care what the "best" answer is. But I would like the character we just created.
So I'd prioritize Wisdom over Intelligence, personally. The opportunity to get 21 at the end of BG1 is there, and really those level one and level two priest spells are excellent, a very nice boost to have right out of the gate. 21 Wisdom is key point for an extra fifth level spell, 22 from Lum's Machine for a second such spell.
Constitution tends to be the hardest of the physical skills to boost regularly. Fewer potions and fewer items that give a boost. So I might prioritize getting a least a 15 or 16 there. Dexterity is the tricky one where it depends on your planned party composition, whether someone else needs the dex gauntlets. Alot of ideal BG1 party setups really do require a frontline companion to hog the gauntlets--Kagain, Ajantis, Yeslick, for example.
So I'd go more 18 Wisdom, 17 dexterity, 16 intelligence, 15 constitution. Charisma and Strength it's meh. As Dave says, Strength potions and items are plentiful. There is a case to be made for high charisma as Friends scrolls drop plenty from early BG1 mobs, and, again, using them strategically, you can get massive discounts and unlock transformative early gear.
You'll probably be doing a bunch of sling and shield on this character in BG1 anyways, so weapon damage output isn't necessarily a huge priority, unless you're a solo run. I'd probably focus on defensive spells from mage combined with disabling spells from priest in the early levels, with that probably reversing a bit in the later levels.
Really stats matter alot alot alot in early BG1, pre-city area. The items are truly limited, the companions too. The scariest challenges are road ambushes that are impossible to prepare for, so you have to rely on your raw stats to survive. The stats are less important as you progress through the saga. So I'd be building mainly to worry about the early BG1 content first and foremost. Keep in mind that your wizard spell progression is going to be very slow and limited in BG1. Topping out at level 3 spells.
Let's immediately agree that Charisma is a dump attribute for this multi-class. Usually, when there is no Cleric or Druid class involved, Wisdom would also be a dump attribute - but that is not the case for an F/M/C. And while Charisma is slightly more useful in BG1, it is still not important enough to invest in, as there will be plenty of gold for anything you want anyway. Plus, in BG2, we will have the charisma ring right away to instantly fix it if needed.
Before going into the rest of the stat allocation, I'd like to mention a few things. The road of min-maxing can be very masochistic. I don't think the task you've set before us should be looked at from the perspective of how to squeeze every little advantage out of an attribute. Doing so will lead to a massive pain in the ass, consuming a lot of time and effort, and some approaches will just put that suffering on repeat. In general, I strongly disagree that constantly using potions to boost attributes is a viable playstyle. In theory, it sounds cool, but in practice, it's a total misery. People bring up potions all the time, as if you can just constantly chug one after another, but in reality, it's just a neat feature used here and there nothing more. And to clarify: I'm talking specifically about attribute-boosting potions, not the general usefulness of potions during hard encounters or for specific tasks.
Take Intelligence, for example. You could use potions to bump it up right before memorizing scrolls so you don't need a high base score. Is that mechanical hassle really worth it? It means you'd have to hoard scrolls throughout the entire saga and then memorize them all in batches after drinking a potion. Because potions are finite, you will constantly feel constrained. Is that feeling worth it over dozens of hours of gameplay just to have a couple of other attributes a bit higher? Sure, dumping Intelligence is a great strategy if you are willing to always put in that extra effort, but I'd rather focus my energy on other aspects of gameplay. My golden mean here would be something like 15 Intelligence. It will get to 16 quick enough to act as a buffer against Mind Flayers - a nice extra cherry on top of your Mage/Cleric buffs. At the same time, you won't suffer in SoA, and you will eventually push it to 17 via Lum and 18 via cards. At that point, you'll only need potions to learn junk spells just to feel good about your character knowing everything, even if the spell is useless.
This same logic applies to Strength. We can rely on items, and luckily, Strength can be increased via equipment quite easily, presumably giving it a lower priority. But the question remains: is locking your belt slot to a strength-setting belt worth it when you have excellent options to improve your AC against specific weapon damage types? Is Dexterity really more important than Strength for a F/M/C? And when exactly do we get Crom Faeyr? Yeah, pretty late. Granted, this multi-class doesn't have that many weapon options anyway, so we could decide to dump Strength because of that. Personally, though, I wouldn't want to suffer through most of the game waiting for Crom Faeyr, and I don't want to be a dumb monk running around with a sling entire time. I might want to dual-wield the Flail of Ages and the Defender of Easthaven, for example, and I would prefer to benefit from extra damage and THAC0 even in BG1, rather than using spells that merely set my Strength to 18 instead of increasing it.
You can apply this thinking to Dexterity as well - the BG1 Gauntlets of Dexterity can compensate for a low score. But does an F/M/C really need to compensate for it forever, or will the Gauntlets of Weapon Expertise serve you much better later in BG1? And what about the Gauntlets of Extraordinary Specialization much, much later in the saga? I think many of us know that even in BG1, you can stack enough AC to make your character pretty OP. So is Dexterity really that much more important than Strength, especially when taking ToB into consideration, where AC matters even less? Again, one could argue that if you know the exact damage types of the enemies in a specific location, a damage-type AC belt will help you more than a +1 or +2 AC bonus from Dexterity. Sure, you can always argue that more AC is better, but you must recognize that you will be lacking in another department because of it. Melee combat will be dominant for an F/M/C throughout most of the saga.
Strength is not a dump stat for an F/M/C. We don't want to spend the whole game relying on potions or spells that override our stat instead of stacking with it - especially since there could always be a better spell memorized in that slot. We also don't want to rely entirely on items because we want the freedom to use other gear that benefits our character more.
If you are playing solo, you are alone against many enemies. At first, logic might dictate that because you are always outnumbered, enemies will land more attacks, meaning you should focus on protection rather than dealing damage. However, the Baldur's Gate rules dictate that an enemy rolling a natural 20 always hits, regardless of how low your AC is. If you are surrounded by multiple enemies, they will collectively roll enough dice to regularly bypass your AC via critical hits. Furthermore, by Baldur's Gate 2, enemy THAC0 values drop so low that standard AC rapidly becomes obsolete against bosses and elite mobs unless you stack hyper-specific endgame gear with a ton of buffs. It gets even worse in ToB. By that time, you will have Stoneskins, Mirror Images, and weapon immunities anyway. On the other hand, if you possess high Strength, you can kill them faster and, in doing so, decrease their total opportunities to hit you in the first place. Remember, we have 3 classes, we won't have such things as alacrity etc., there will be plenty of physical combat. So it all essentially boils down to BG1. As I said earlier, I'd rather struggle a bit in BG1 than throughout the entire saga - and besides, there are already plenty of easy ways to handle those early-game problems. Moreover, you don't have to wear robes as F/M/C in BG1 at all times. In fact, at times you would benefit more by forgetting that you're a Mage entirely and playing as if you're just a Fighter/Cleric wearing heavy armor
So what kind of experience do we want from this playthrough? We could prioritize minimizing our suffering in BG1, but that will prolong a different kind of mediocrity. Alternatively, we could suffer a bit more in BG1 but have an easier time from then on. What would be your preference?
The priority of Wisdom is pretty easy to determine for this multi-class: it is vital. As others have mentioned, it grants extra spell slots. This should be our most valued attribute.
As for Constitution, the more HP the better, and we should mostly rely on a permanent baseline stat here. I know there are crazy pros who do solo playthroughs with minimum Constitution - good for them, well done - but personally, I prefer a higher margin for error to deal with the randomness of the dice. This attribute is incredibly important to me, and for an F/M/C.
The balance between CON and STR directly depends on what choices you plan to make in the final Hell trials.
So, for me, the priority is: WIS 18 > CON / STR > INT 15 > DEX 14 > CHA
But I'm sure you could do pretty well with this too: STR 18 > CON 17 > DEX 16 > INT 15 > WIS 14 > CHA. This alternative focuses on maximizing physical optimization for the first half of the trilogy, while letting your Wisdom and Intelligence climb over time. By the time you get to SoA, your arcane and divine power will start catching up anyway. Well, minus the extra cleric spells. Still very strong. Cause we will be looking at STR 20-22 / CON 19-20 / DEX 18 / INT 18 / WIS 18-19 depending on the tear trial choices.
Just gonna note that, in my experience, this isn't true at all. And rather than careful usage of intelligence potions being something that's tedious, it's actually something that makes the game more fun. It engages you as a player more with the strategic elements of the game. It is, after all, an RTS engine running a cRPG, based on a tabletop ruleset that was lifted from from strategy wargaming tabletops. Additionally, if you were a mage living in such a fantasy world, this is what you would do! Being strategic here is not like some cheesing strategies. It fits perfectly within the roleplay of the game world.!
First of all, you're only getting two level three spells at the end of BG1. You don't need to memorize many mage spells.
Secondly, potions last long enough that you can chug them at the start of a dungeon or a wilderness area and then use that benefit to help in identifying items (this will be a good lore class) in addition to benefit of better scroll odds. Lastly, even with an 18 intelligence, if you aren't reloading, you're going to want to chug potions for scrolls. Just as you would use the benefit from potions of defense, strength, heroism, etc, to help you clear a hostile area. That's how the game was designed to played!
Holy moly!