Skip to content

Siege of Dragonspear Review Thread - Feedback for Devs and Information for Prospective Players

PurudayaPurudaya Member Posts: 816
I've seen quite a few people on this forum who are frustrated at not being able to get decent information about the game's content because of all the hubbub going on. Similarly, I've seen developers express frustration that they're not getting as much helpful constructive feedback as they would like for the same reason.

So if you've played or are playing the game, feel free to use this space to write your own review of SoD and give it a 1-5 star rating below. It can be a page or three lines - just let the devs and prospective players know what your *experience* has been in the game thus far. And if you feel so inclined, don't hesitate to leave a copy of your positive, negative, or mixed review on GoG, Metacritic, or Steam. If you haven't played the game and want to know more about its content, this might be a good place to consolidate your questions.

Finally, an idea to keep this thread civil: if you see a review that you disagree with or feel is intended to provoke, don't reply to it. Let's stick to the facts so that prospective players and devs can get some detailed information and constructive feedback.

So...how would you rate the game?

Note: keep an eye on which ratings actually have reviews that go with them :wink:
  1. Siege of Dragonspear Review Thread - Feedback for Devs and Information for Prospective Players33 votes
    1. 5 Stars/All the Stars
      21.21%
    2. 4 Stars
      63.64%
    3. 3 Stars
        3.03%
    4. 2 Stars
        3.03%
    5. 1 Star/No Stars
        6.06%
    6. Other: 6 quasars, 2.7 nebulas, etc.
        3.03%
[Deleted User]IllustairNonnahswriter

Comments

  • PurudayaPurudaya Member Posts: 816
    edited April 2016
    I'll Start:

    Although there were some exceptions (I didn't care so much for Corwin's VO), the new characters were varied and had enjoyable banters, especially Glint (who also had the most talented voice acting, imho). As for the existing characters, hearing Minsc, Imoen and others for the first time in 15 years has been surreal.

    The gameplay offered some unique encounters, though occasionally the respawns made things a little tedious - I found myself abusing the rest system a little more here than I have in other parts of the series. Large-scale battles, however, were a blast and presented a whole new set of challenges.

    As for player options, I really liked the new race and class-specific dialogues. This came into play in the very first dungeon, where my Mage was able to bypass a fetch quest with his arcane knowledge. Very cool.

    Bugs: I've only really encountered one, which had to do with an item that lacked a permanent drop flag. I've had two crashes to desktop in roughly 20 hours of play, and one of those was when I was playing around with the new real-time UI editor (which is awesome, btw). Other than that, my experience has been smooth sailing. I'm playing an unmodded version, but I've heard mods are not affected. Multiplayer, on the other hand, is apparently pretty buggy.

    What most struck me about this expansion, despite its flaws, is how much it felt like Baldur's Gate. It really does feel like coming back home to the game, if that makes any sense - something that the previous Beamdog original content (while decent), didn't achieve 100%. Beamdog has expanded its team and resource pool significantly since then, and it shows - this really feels like a fitting addition to the series. All in all, I feel more confident in Beamdog's caretaking of this franchise than I have since joining this forum 3 years ago. Can't wait to see what they do next.
    [Deleted User]TStaelButtercheeseillathid
  • rjmacreadyrjmacready Member Posts: 91
    edited April 2016
    I dont have much time before I turn in for the night so Ill be brief.

    Plot:

    Its like a non-epic level but more involved throne of bhaal meets Icewind Dale. Sure it can be a tad linear at times but its ground well within the confines of the expedition. You cant spend a week out in the wilderness because the expedition needs you.

    The tie in to BG2 is fantastic. My only criticism is they maybe got a teensy bit carried away because there is a surprising amount of this forshadowing for BG2. However that is forgiveable because firstly -David Freakin Warner - and secondly BG2 is actually rather light on its villain outside of dreams so this in a way beefs it up some.

    The antagonst is great. She had me switching from one thing to the next and I just struggled to pin it down. Is she a charismatic leader or an unwitting pawn? Righteous and arrogant or selfish and scared?

    The gameplay

    This one isnt too hard. The AI improvments are great as are the enemy adjustments for difficulty. The massed combat was excellent too. Its just more BG combat but with extra dimensions added.

    The music was great and perfectly blended old tracks with new elements as well as some awesome fresh new music too.

    Those voice actors who returned did briliantly as did a few returnees from BG2 and Icewind Dale who played prominant roles in them. So did the new arrivals. Also the character writing was great too especially when written to take into account what comes in bg2.

    Im extremely lucky in that my experience has been free of nearly all major bugs and technical faults. The only significant issue is a minor annoyance in that a few areas have fluctuating frame rates for some odd reason. Yet when I played the titular "Siege" with nigh on a hundred or more sprites nuking eachother the game ran superbly.

    In short nostalgia helped but its much more than that. Its now an inseperable part of the saga for me. BG2 can no longer be started anymore unless Siege of Dragonspear has been finished. 5 stars - I loves it!
    Purudaya[Deleted User]EnialusMeliamneillathid
  • TenreccTenrecc Member Posts: 265
    edited April 2016
    Feel like I've done this so many times already. I'll sum it up quickly.

    + Story. I only used custom chars so can't judge the NPCs, but I found it really good. Hearing Imoen and Irenicus again was awesome. Caelar was really well-done, realistic and believable, far from your run of the mill villain. Especially the ending was amazing, both the "journey" and the "judgment." Really felt like they captured some of that grim uncomfortable feeling in BG1, when you were on the run from the law and people despised you, questioning who you really were.

    + Combat. In a time where every single game gets dumbed down so immensely that even my blind, senile grandmother can beat "hard mode" in the first try, they stayed true to having challenging content, even for veterans such as myself who ran a fairly OP party setup. Especially the dragon and final boss required me to reload a few times and execute the fights correctly, and felt very rewarding to beat.

    - Linear. While they didn't fall for todays pitfall of easy gameplay, they fell for a really linear story, prefering to tell their own story over giving people the tools of telling their own. First of all, that's strictly against what the BG series is about, which is open world exploration and you deciding when to move the story forward, and it also gives it very, very low replayability. SoD is very unlikely to become a part of my playthroughs for this reason alone. Maybe once or twice more, but far, far from everyone.

    - Buggy. Don't really need to go into this I feel.

    Overall, my current score is 3/5, but I'm assuming the bugs will be fixed asap, which will raise it to 4/5 imho. I would love to give it 5/5, but the fact that it carries so very, very little replayability makes me unable to. In order to get 5/5 in my book, with a game that linear and strict, it'd have to be a true masterpiece like Planescape Torment. And as much as I liked the story, it was nowhere near that.

    Ok, that wasn't quickly. At all. :P
    Purudaya[Deleted User]
  • athakathak Member Posts: 31
    One more thing - it's linear. No BG game is so linear as SoD.
    GodKaiserHellFoggy
  • rjmacreadyrjmacready Member Posts: 91
    athak said:

    One more thing - it's linear. No BG game is so linear as SoD.

    Id argue if ToB isnt AS linear its only a hairs breadth away. Your only freedom really is which order to attack the boss dungeons of Sendai or Abazigal. Other than that its watchers keep or bust with little else but the main plot.
    [Deleted User]illathid
  • PurudayaPurudaya Member Posts: 816
    I agree that it was linear, but at least the game sort of gave you a reason for it in the narrative - it didn't feel as artificially railroaded as Throne of Bhaal. I do wish that they could have left all the southern areas of the SoD map accessible before crossing Boareskyr bridge.
    [Deleted User]
  • wraith5641wraith5641 Member Posts: 500
    Thank you for making this thread.

    I haven't played the game yet, but it's good to see real fans taking the initiative and giving helpful information to the devs and new players where it seems to be pretty scarce at the moment. It's a much brighter community when we are all sharing our wisdom.
    [Deleted User]PurudayaIllustair
  • athakathak Member Posts: 31

    athak said:

    One more thing - it's linear. No BG game is so linear as SoD.

    Id argue if ToB isnt AS linear its only a hairs breadth away. Your only freedom really is which order to attack the boss dungeons of Sendai or Abazigal. Other than that its watchers keep or bust with little else but the main plot.
    True. Don't forget when ToB was released, and why did they do it in such a short ammount of time. There's is a lot of information about it in Ascension readme file, so browse through it. Alas, ToB has it's many flaws beside linearity; hackmaster equipment, hackmaster spells and HLAs and so on. That's no excuse for SoD however.
    atakdogGodKaiserHellFoggy
  • The user and all related content has been deleted.
    Purudaya
  • PurudayaPurudaya Member Posts: 816
    @typo_tilly You know what I really missed? A village! I would have loved a map with a war-torn Beregost equivalent, for example.
    [Deleted User]illathid
  • YupImMadBroYupImMadBro Member, Mobile Tester Posts: 347
    I have not yet completed the game but I have hit some important milestones and feel like I can add some input.

    I believe this game is doing everything it went out to achieve. One of the complaints about the game is that it is too linear. I am not here to argue against that but rather, I believe that it actually makes the game run smoother. For a bit, I actually felt rushed in the game and then I realized that it was on purpose. There is an attempt to take your life. You have to gather some near by allies and reach the Coalition. You have to confront the Crusade in one way or another. Realistically, there isn't much time to hang around. I was so immersed in the game; getting caught up in the emotion, that I forgot that I could pause and walk away from the game. I believe that this was the goal of the game.

    That being said, there are additional areas that can be explored and side quests that can be completed that still give SoD that classic Baldur's Gate feel.

    I cannot comment on the new joinable NPCs as I have only played with Corwin for awhile but I did enjoy my time with her.

    The one thing that I have enjoyed the most was reconnecting with old characters. Hearing new lines from Minsc never gets old. I have to admit, I smile every time Minsc recites his fatigue line. Not to mention, yelling at my monitors to tell Khalid to shut up every time he shows his lack of confidence, brings up some old memories.

    Overall, I believe that if you're considering getting this game and have played BG and BG2, you owe yourself to get this game.
    [Deleted User]Purudaya
  • TStaelTStael Member Posts: 861
    I've about 15 hours on the campaign at the moment, so reasonably robust view, I'd guess. Rated it four stars.

    I must admit I am not extremely wild about the new content on EE, so managed my expectations quite low as not to be disappointed, but I'm genuinely enjoying the campaign. It essentially extends the BG gaming joy, and I would take any amount of that.


    + Old friends! Very impressed and thankful that so many of the original, well loved voice actors are back
    + I actually find the new NPCs quite interesting, and personally will have replay value there (wanting to ultimately bring everyone along)
    + Combat is quite challenging in a good way. Have needed some reloads on "core rules"
    + I'm genuinely keen to see how the story ends! I've already raved how much I love Irenicus story device, but really enjoy all his appearances. Love that Imoen gets major attention and backstory.
    + Small AI improvement, but I like that healers heal you without prompted
    + Your main antagonist is a character one can respect, I find her interesting character

    - It's quite linear but that's pretty much norm for expansions and DLC
    - Due to linearity, the replay cycle will be that much longer
    - Maybe that's bit kitchy but I was dying for a merchant in the starting dungeon as my gembags and scroll cases did not import!
    - I've not encountered big bugs, some equipment not exporting, and only a few game impacting ones, e.g. one where I think a given torch in a cave just was bugged and could not be interacted with
    [Deleted User]Purudaya
  • skeptik_59skeptik_59 Member Posts: 38
    Excellent idea for a thread. I don't have anything other than that to contribute :) , but good idea. I've enjoyed reading the reviews so far.
    [Deleted User]
  • TStaelTStael Member Posts: 861
    edited April 2016
    PS. I wonder if it's only me, but the notion of a
    dwarven lich
    just cracked me!

    (Simply a quite unusual creature, just fyi. First time I've seen one in a game thus far, I think!)
    [Deleted User]
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 0
    edited April 2016
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • PurudayaPurudaya Member Posts: 816
    edited April 2016
    TStael said:

    PS. I wonder if it's only me, but the notion of a dwarven lich just cracked me!

    I really liked the combat mechanic they threw in so we could believably take him down at level 9. I want to import that stone into BG2 and use it on Kangaax :smiley:
  • TStaelTStael Member Posts: 861

    @TStael Spoiler that creature name! :u Some haven't gotten there yet. :)

    Per your request tilly.
    [Deleted User]
Sign In or Register to comment.