Skip to content

Dragons without arcane caster

ArtonaArtona Member Posts: 1,077
in Baldur's Gate II: Enhanced Edition
Hi, fellow users. Is it possible to beat dragons without mage or sorcerer or bard? I'm currently playing with an evil party: my Bhaalspawn, assassin dual-classed to warrior, fallen blackguard Dorn, Hexxat and Viconia. I took Bodhi's offer too soon, before completing Bloodscalp quest. Therefore, I don't have access to Edwin.
Right now I'm doing fine, but I wonder if that party would work against dragons.

So, my question: should I get Jan or Haer'Dalis, or is possible to deal without them?
«1

Comments

  • Lord_TansheronLord_Tansheron Member Posts: 4,211
    If you're playing the unmodded game, you can absolutely just bash down dragons without casting any spell whatsoever. Of course, it might be harder and take longer, but it's entirely possible. Also you do have divine casters, which can help a lot.

    So no, arcane casters aren't mandatory; for anything in the unmodded game, really.
  • RobertMcDuckRobertMcDuck Member Posts: 133
    Having an Arcane caster is always good, byt as Lord_Tansheron said, they are not vital.
  • SirBatinceSirBatince Member Posts: 882
    If unmodded, all you gotta do is punch the stoneskin away. If you're lazy and cheesy you can just trigger the fight, run and rest, engage again. No more spells.
  • rapsam2003rapsam2003 Member Posts: 1,636
    I mean, yeah...it's fully possible. But I also feel like it's not as fun. Letting your fighters tie up the dragons and then using Magic Missile several times is so...effective. :D
  • Mush_MushMush_Mush Member Posts: 476
    edited May 2016
    Druid with iron skins 2x conjure animals + Inquisitor + cleric with aerial servant + maybe some badass archers or kensai types buff them all with divine spells, potions and prot scrolls, probably go down pretty easy.

    Don't think its too hard to kill dragons without arcane might. Killing them without any kind of magic however would be an impressive feat. :smile:

    Edit: Actually, I suppose it depends on the dragon in question and what level your party is at. It would be impressive, for example, if you killed off Firkragg before Spellhold without magic but not so much say the dragon in Watchers Keep with a ToB party.
  • marzbarzmarzbarz Member Posts: 187
    Slayer form!
  • NuinNuin Member Posts: 451
    edited May 2016
    Once you become more experienced with the game you can even try fighting dragons without a mage/priest class, modded or otherwise. It will be challenging, but other people have managed to pull it off.

    Just take the time to study what everybody can do so you know what your options are. And remember, you don't have to fight any of the game's dragons at low-mid levels. You can always come back when everyone has better gear/more levels.
  • lunarlunar Member Posts: 3,460
    Viconia's harm spell can bring down a dragon quite easily. You should buff her thac0, with spells and strength items, and then hope that dragon's mr won't resist it.
  • Sids1188Sids1188 Member Posts: 165
    If you want to be cheesy, you can also have yourself and Hexxat cover the area with traps. Spike traps if you have HLAs. Those alone should leave the dragon in shambles.
  • MacHurtoMacHurto Member Posts: 731
    edited May 2016
    Spike trap spam is no fun. I only used it on my no reload run as I was just scared of dying all the time.

    In any case with access to HLAs all SoA dragons should fall easily
  • MacHurtoMacHurto Member Posts: 731
    Haha I would make a terrible Lord of Murder, I know :-D

    Anyway, I was scared of dying at the final ToB fight and having to redo my only ever no reload from the beginning. Using the spikes was on character in any case, as my gnome had just become a dad with Aerie right before the fight and dying (and losing his essence) meant he could not become a God and escape his terrible mortal fate.
  • ArtonaArtona Member Posts: 1,077
    edited May 2016
    Okay, you convinced me. But if I fail horribly, it's on your heads - and fear my wrath, because it is great indeed... ;)
    I'll update my thread after Firkraag or Shadow Dragon.

    And one more question - is Demogorgon killable without mage? Or that nasty party before him?

    Edit: Actually, I suppose it depends on the dragon in question and what level your party is at. It would be impressive, for example, if you killed off Firkragg before Spellhold without magic but not so much say the dragon in Watchers Keep with a ToB party.
    I usually do all Alkhatla quests before Spellhold, so I'll probably attempt to slay him.

    If unmodded, all you gotta do is punch the stoneskin away. If you're lazy and cheesy you can just trigger the fight, run and rest, engage again. No more spells.
    I am lazy and cheesy, but not that lazy and cheesy. But thanks for the advice. :D

    If you want to be cheesy, you can also have yourself and Hexxat cover the area with traps.
    I'll use it as last resort.

    Thanks for tips, everybody. :)
  • Sids1188Sids1188 Member Posts: 165
    At least if you need to, by the time you reach ToB you'll have access to a final evil NPC that can dual to mage. If you're struggling at that point (or with Watchers Keep), you will be able to fill the hole. Might not be as satisfying that way, however.
  • jtthjtth Member Posts: 171
    To confirm for the SCS crew: this is practically impossible with SCS, right?
  • Lord_TansheronLord_Tansheron Member Posts: 4,211
    jtth said:

    To confirm for the SCS crew: this is practically impossible with SCS, right?

    SCS doesn't require casters either, but it gets SIGNIFICANTLY easier if you have a caster of any kind (arcane or divine). I seem to recall reading somewhere that you can beat anything in SCS except Ascension without any caster whatsoever, but I'm not sure as I've never tried it myself.
  • NuinNuin Member Posts: 451
    edited May 2016
    I've heard of people soloing Tactics and Tactics + Ascension without casters. SCS + other difficulty mods should be doable if you go with mostly AI changes, and someone out there has probably beaten it without a caster. SCS is a relatively new mod though, so there can't be that many who have done it.
  • jackjackjackjack Member Posts: 3,251
    A cursory glance at google shows threads about SCS dating back to 2006, and that was just a post saying it had been updated to work with BGT/TuTu. I wouldn't call it a new mod at this point.
  • NuinNuin Member Posts: 451
    edited May 2016
    Ascension is probably the closest thing to an official mod BG2 has and was released not long after ToB came out, so we won't discuss that.
    The SCS you know today didn't exactly spring from the modders' minds fully formed. When Tactics was released (about 2-3 years after ToB came out) it was crude and unfair, but most of the insane difficulty content was already there. Extra revisions mostly just removed the bugs/painfully simple exploits.

    IIRC, SCS was first released as a BG1 mod in 2006. Then they made a version for BG2 a while later, and have been steadily working on it (major release every few years) since then. The version people now play took years of meticulous work by modders, because the idea was that they did not want it to be as unfair as Tactics.
  • Lord_TansheronLord_Tansheron Member Posts: 4,211
    SCS is inspired by Tactics, but has the explicitly stated goal of achieving "fair" difficulty - i.e. that if at all possible, the AI should not do things the player cannot. Note however that in order to properly simulate that, the WAY in which it is done is often "unfair" - one example would be pre-buffing, which due to engine constraints is handled by having enemy casters cast a gazillion buffs at once at the beginning of combat via an (uninterruptable) script. Not fair in a technical sense, but fair in its effect as you as a player also go into a fight fully buffed.

    Of course, SCS is a tactical mod intended for people who want a combat challenge. RP concerns are usually secondary (e.g. "why does the mage have pre-buffs they are at home and not expecting a fight").
  • lunarlunar Member Posts: 3,460
    edited May 2016
    Well if I were a high lvl mage staying at home in a dangerous place like Fearun, I would cast stoneskin and various armor/long lasting protection spells each morning even before brushing my teeth. And conjure up a few invisible servants to do the house chores. Oh yes that would have been perfect!
    ...if I was a wild mage I would probably skip the invisible servants, though. No need to risk a nabassu or exploding cow at me home.
  • NuinNuin Member Posts: 451
    edited May 2016
    Reasons why you probably wouldn't do that if you actually lived on Faerun:

    1) Spellcasting requires components. In some cases, EXPENSIVE components. That's why most spellcasters save their spells for actual combat.
    2) Most of these spells were designed for combat. Out of combat, you are basically at the mercy of DMs.
    Something like: "you stubbed your toe, -1 stoneskin" or "a mosquito tried to bite you, -1 stoneskin" or "you absently flick your hand and accidentally set the living room curtains on fire with an MMM" would be perfectly acceptable side effects for using spells like these out of combat.
    3) You're a high level mage. Act like one. Install traps/alarms/magical failsafes/use contingencies and sequencers instead of walking around with full buffs like a disaster waiting to happen.
  • ArtonaArtona Member Posts: 1,077
    I wouldn't play with that kind of DM. "You stubbed your toe, -1 stoneskin" sounds for me like "I just wanna ruin your fun".
  • rapsam2003rapsam2003 Member Posts: 1,636
    Nuin said:

    1) Spellcasting requires components. In some cases, EXPENSIVE components. That's why most spellcasters save their spells for actual combat.

    And this is why any arcane caster worth their salt would have an arcane focus.
    Nuin said:

    2) Most of these spells were designed for combat. Out of combat, you are basically at the mercy of DMs.
    Something like: "you stubbed your toe, -1 stoneskin" or "a mosquito tried to bite you, -1 stoneskin" or "you absently flick your hand and accidentally set the living room curtains on fire with an MMM" would be perfectly acceptable side effects for using spells like these out of combat.

    Bahahaha, your DM must hate you.

    That's why actual high level mages install traps/alarms/magical failsafes/use contingencies and sequencers instead of walking around fully buffed.
    I much prefer the Ammon Jerro method. Bind a bunch of demons to my dungeon, then let jackass adventures get tricked into dying. Only fails to work if my granddaughter happens to ruin it.
  • NuinNuin Member Posts: 451
    edited May 2016
    It's perfectly acceptable. Note that you are trying RP someone who is basically just waiting for some random "adventurers" to arrive and try to kill you. So you're constantly re-casting protective spells and then waiting for days, weeks, months...

    I'd be surprised if your (very) bored DM wasn't already trying to roll consecutive 20s just to try and justify triggering some sort of disaster.
  • FinnTheHumanFinnTheHuman Member Posts: 404
    I think its pretty save to RP that they heard you coming. Probably heard you chanting and casting protections right outside their door. Bunch of metal clad barbarians clanging up the stairs. Did you think you were being sneaky?
  • OtherguyOtherguy Member Posts: 157
    Why oh why would anyone play without an arcane caster? Improved haste alone is like having twice as many fighters in your party.

    Granted I only play with SCS, but even so. No class is "needed" but I would definately give an arcane caster top priority. Impr haste, ruby ray, breach, secret word, true sight, various crowd control and maybe even a summon or two makes the game a lot easier and imho more fun.

    Jan is a very strong NPC, I would strongly advice you to replace Hexxat with him.

    The tiefling is also strong but imho he should be left in prison.
  • ArtonaArtona Member Posts: 1,077
    Why oh why would anyone play without an arcane caster?
    Because I play evil party, and there is only one evil wizard, and I have no access to him due to dealing with Bodhi.
  • NuinNuin Member Posts: 451
    edited May 2016
    The thing about arguments like these (they should hear you coming, they have scouts/scrying spells/etc) is that you could also argue that experienced adventurers have ways to get around that.

    You ARE travelling with (powerful) priests, druids, mages, rogues...
    I never understood why these mods make it sound like every PC party is the crass/blunt type when game gives you a lot of NPCs with thieving/diplomatic/information-gathering abilities and when spells like Invisibility 10' Radius cost a mere level 3 spell slot. Hell, if your PC is a rogue you have an entire thieves' guild branch to do all your information-gathering for you.
    "When does he normally take a bath? That must be when he dismisses his Stoneskin/MMM spell..."

    While I do like how SCS raises difficulty and use it anyway, the logic behind these changes is truly baffling. Granted, it would be hard to truly justify these kind of changes unless most of the enemy adventurers you fight were actually in league with someone like Bodhi all along (or were receiving intel from her).
    Post edited by Nuin on
  • AewyrvenAewyrven Member Posts: 228
    edited May 2016
    Artona said:

    Hi, fellow users. Is it possible to beat dragons without mage or sorcerer or bard? I'm currently playing with an evil party: my Bhaalspawn, assassin dual-classed to warrior, fallen blackguard Dorn, Hexxat and Viconia. I took Bodhi's offer too soon, before completing Bloodscalp quest. Therefore, I don't have access to Edwin.
    Right now I'm doing fine, but I wonder if that party would work against dragons.

    So, my question: should I get Jan or Haer'Dalis, or is possible to deal without them?

    Without reading others posts, and without having access to dorm or hexxat atm. ..

    Yeah you can drop the shadow dragon and firkraag. By the time you get to the silver dragon in terms underdark you can probably drop her too using just you and viconia.

    For Thalys (shadow drago) just have viconia memorize a couple of sanctuaries, protection evil, and remove fears. Then use your sin to backstab with potions of invisible.

    Firkraag gonna be tougher but go hit up the inn in waukeens for the cloak of non detect and repeat through. Depending what weapons your sin is using will depend on the potions u need. (You can get fire potions easily and viconia can acid/frost resist you)

    Drop some traps prior to fight (it's not too cheesy since those 2 dragons you won't have the trap of cheese)

    Make sure you poison weapon as it will do the bulk of your damage through all their protections. Have viconia also buff you with strength of one if you don't have str items and bless. She can also summon a few skeletons and Ariel servants (servants if levels high enough) prior to the fight to eat the dragon death spells. (And since ur spread around the dragon it'll only hit 1 or 2 of the summons, not all of them, or you)

    Key to it though is park your guys around the dragon at like a 12 3 5 9 rotation before starting. Don't just charge in.

Sign In or Register to comment.

2024 Overhaul Games, a division of Beamdog. © 2024 Hasbro, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Baldur's Gate, Dungeons & Dragons, D&D, Forgotten Realms, Baldur's Gate, Wizards of the Coast and their logos are trademarks of Wizards of the Coast LLC in the U.S.A. and other countries, and are used with permission. Hasbro and its logo are trademarks of Hasbro, Inc. and are used with permission. © 1998 BioWare Corp. All Rights Reserved. BioWare, the BioWare Infinity Engine and the BioWare logo are trademarks of Bioware Corp. Black Isle Studios and the Black Isle Studios logo are trademarks of Interplay Entertainment Corp. Atari and the Atari logo are trademarks owned by Atari Interactive, Inc. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.