Great ideas! The Anniversary and Facebook connector definitely clash with the other icons.
Maybe using just the Slow scroll for Anniversaries, along with the appropriate number in the lower right-hand corner, would be better. Having several different scrolls might make for confusion.
The Dimension Door scroll seems best for the Facebook connector.
I like your Ancient Anniversary idea, but what would be the criteria for awarding it?
How about the "Friends" spell icon for the Facebook badge? Isn't adding someone on Facebook called "Friending"? (I don't use Facebook, so forgive my ignorance.)
I'm trying to think of something good for the ten year and ancient member badges. Also looking into returning the Hyper Chicken to its previous giffy glory. @Shandy Yes it is hideous to scale something that was 16px tall by 10.
Comments
Maybe using just the Slow scroll for Anniversaries, along with the appropriate number in the lower right-hand corner, would be better. Having several different scrolls might make for confusion.
The Dimension Door scroll seems best for the Facebook connector.
I like your Ancient Anniversary idea, but what would be the criteria for awarding it?
Too lazy to write "your" :P