warblade would be a nice weapon if it didn't come so late. who's gonna use that when by then you already have the silver sword, carsomyr (if good), dragon's breath, and soul reaver? all of which are better.
Depends on your choices, but it is + 5 vs good inherently, so it should hit as a +5 weapon. I've not tested it though.
The unholy Reaver from watchers keep is +5.
It's always worth remembering the upgraded mace of disruption hits at +5.
Mace of disruption was my first thought. It's super easy to acquire and it's effectively a +5 weapon. Staff of the magi is great too but much much harder to get, especially early on.
Comments
Cutthroat (+4 short sword)
Crom Feyer (+4 Warhammer)
Kneecapper (+1/+4 vs giant creatures hits as a +4 weapon)
Staff of Rynn (+4 staff)
Staff of the Magi (+1, strikes as a +5 weapon)
Spear of Withering (+4 spear)
Warblade (+4 2hsword that deals d12+4dmg)
Holy Avenger (+5 2h sword)
Soul Reaver (+4 2h sword)
Dragon's Breath (+4 halbard)
The Wave (another +4 halbard)
Blackmist (yet another +4 halbard)
Azuredge (strikes as a +4 weapon)
I think that is all for SoA. There are a bunch more for ToB
The unholy Reaver from watchers keep is +5.
It's always worth remembering the upgraded mace of disruption hits at +5.
rookie mistake
I think twinkle only hits as a +3 even though it is technically a +5 defender that you just can't alter ratio of defense/attack for.
Mace of disruption was my first thought. It's super easy to acquire and it's effectively a +5 weapon. Staff of the magi is great too but much much harder to get, especially early on.