Skip to content

Where do you think Shank and Carbos ended up after their failed assassinations?

Thrown over the walls of Candlekeep? Burned? Fed to the dogs? Destroyed by some wizardly spell? Ressurected and turned to stone?

Voice your opinion!

Comments

  • ajwzajwz Member Posts: 4,122
    They make a cameo in BG2 as @SapphireIce101 mentioned
  • Ah yes! I remember Bubbles but didn't think it was Shank and Carbos. Deary me! I wonder how they got out of Candlekeep?
  • SharGuidesMyHandSharGuidesMyHand Member Posts: 2,580
    Huh? They ended up exploded into pieces last time I remember.

    Thrown over the walls of Candlekeep? Burned? Fed to the dogs? Destroyed by some wizardly spell? Ressurected and turned to stone?

    Huh? They ended up exploded into tiny pieces last time I remember.
  • CoM_SolaufeinCoM_Solaufein Member Posts: 2,607
    Worm food.
  • BladeDancerBladeDancer Member Posts: 477
    Cremated. Shank and Carbos were poor residents of Candlekeep looking to make easy money, nothing more.
  • SionIVSionIV Member Posts: 2,689
    I was almost expecting to see them in ToB at Abiz dragon lair, having joined that adventure party.
  • SCARY_WIZARDSCARY_WIZARD Member Posts: 1,438
    Anduin said:

    They became cheap animal feed for Nessie the cow...

    Nessie was sold for animal feed and taken south Nashkell at a fair rate of knots due to bandits in the area... Luckily, the bandits were not interested in cattle rustlin...

    As you know, the crops pretty much failed in Nashkell, even with the help of a generous spreading of manure, they failed.

    Luckily a Druid cast a resurrection spell on the crops and was quite surprised to see Shank and Carbos spring out of the ground...

    The strange event was heard in Amn. The cowled wizards fearing unlicensed wizardry forcibly escorted the duo to be trialled for practicing necromantic heresy... Who finally worked out what a sorry state they ended up in to get there... They repeated the experiment a few times... Feeding them to animals and resurrecting the excrement... The espionage potential was interesting, but was flawed in that no spy would willingly submit to it...

    Finally, an aunty of one of the Cowled wizards, Bubbles, took pity on the pair and ate them cunningly disguised as a Cornish pasty.

    After re-emerging into the world, they feel reborn, and have fallen in love with their erstwhile saviour...

    However, the manner and method of their saving is a taboo subject, and never, ever discussed.

    ...

    Shank and Carbos to this day cannot look a Cornish pasty in the eye...

    "Hmm, heh, chicken-fried steak!"
  • AnduinAnduin Member Posts: 5,745
    Apologies for the amount of typos in that response...
  • Permidion_StarkPermidion_Stark Member Posts: 4,861
    I didn't go into either of the buildings they were in so they are probably still there waiting for me.
  • LateralusLateralus Member Posts: 903
    edited September 2013
    One time, Shank chased me all over Candle Keep. he stabbed me THREE TIMES in front of Gorion, Imoen, and Tethtoril. Every single guard ignored my cries for help and my foster father watched me get stabbed to death at the base of the stairs. Needless to say, there was A LOT running through my mind in those final moments of life...

    Usually, when I am a good guy, I knock them unconscious and pretend to tell Fuller about it so he can lock them up and have them stand trial. Since I wont be there to state my case against them, they will be allowed to go free pending a subsequent investigation on how two impoverished rogues managed to present 10,000 gold pieces in entry fees. Of which they would likely be found guilty, seeing as how they likely scaled the keeps walls and did not sign the log in book. For that, they would be put down with sword thrusts to the spine.
  • MukoraMukora Member Posts: 14

    Cremated. Shank and Carbos were poor residents of Candlekeep looking to make easy money, nothing more.

    This might be from a mod, but I seem to recall meeting a relative of theirs in Baldur's Gate who said they didn't live in Candlekeep.
  • elminsterelminster Member, Developer Posts: 16,315
    Mukora said:

    Cremated. Shank and Carbos were poor residents of Candlekeep looking to make easy money, nothing more.

    This might be from a mod, but I seem to recall meeting a relative of theirs in Baldur's Gate who said they didn't live in Candlekeep.
    You meet a woman in Baldur's Gate (the city) who briefly mentions them. I don't think she specifies where they lived immediately prior to their attempts to assassinate you.
  • scriverscriver Member Posts: 2,072
    Carbos and Shank had taken hire as servants or guards of the visiting nobles and scholars, and got in as part of their entourages. That's how I see things, at least.
  • JalilyJalily Member Posts: 4,681
    edited September 2013
    Mukora said:

    Cremated. Shank and Carbos were poor residents of Candlekeep looking to make easy money, nothing more.

    This might be from a mod, but I seem to recall meeting a relative of theirs in Baldur's Gate who said they didn't live in Candlekeep.
    She doesn't say where they're from, and she's not a relative—Carbos and Shank owed her a lot of money, so she pretended to be in order to find out their whereabouts.

    Carbos's dialogue, however, makes it clear he's not from Candlekeep: "Someone seems to think you're trouble, so I'm gonna use your head for a ticket out o' the gutter! I'm just a little street trash hood they say, but I'll show 'em!"

    Carbos also gives this bit of foreshadowing:
    "Foster child. Gotta keep it straight. He raised you as his own, but you are not of his blood. Your head ain't worth nothing if you're actually his child. Nah, I know you're the right one. My ticket out of the gutter, soon as I snuff your lights."
    Now, where could he have learned that?

    Personally, I think they're from Baldur's Gate.
  • SionIVSionIV Member Posts: 2,689
    I'm just shocked that someone actually hired them to do the job. Imagine if you had walked in on Slythe and Krystin instead. Who the hell would pay 10 000 gold or the like to get Shank and Carbos in....
  • scriverscriver Member Posts: 2,072
    I don't think they were hired directly, unlike some of the later, more powerful, assassins. I would think that the "bounties" on CHARNAME was just being passed out into the right circles, and Carbos and Shank had connections or just happened upon them through bad luck.
  • SionIVSionIV Member Posts: 2,689
    scriver said:

    I don't think they were hired directly, unlike some of the later, more powerful, assassins. I would think that the "bounties" on CHARNAME was just being passed out into the right circles, and Carbos and Shank had connections or just happened upon them through bad luck.

    And how did they get into Candlekeep then? And i have seen those walls, i don't think either of them could scale that.
  • KaltzorKaltzor Member Posts: 1,050
    There, and there, and there, and little over here...
  • doggydoggy Member Posts: 313
    I wonder who would spend the gold raising those two guys. The cow theory is funny though...
  • SionIVSionIV Member Posts: 2,689
    edited September 2013
    doggy said:

    I wonder who would spend the gold raising those two guys. The cow theory is funny though...

    Baeloth : I shall pay to ressurect these two powerful champions, and with that start the Black Pits Season 2.. Mwahahahahah!
  • scriverscriver Member Posts: 2,072
    SionIV said:

    scriver said:

    I don't think they were hired directly, unlike some of the later, more powerful, assassins. I would think that the "bounties" on CHARNAME was just being passed out into the right circles, and Carbos and Shank had connections or just happened upon them through bad luck.

    And how did they get into Candlekeep then? And i have seen those walls, i don't think either of them could scale that.
    *Points a few posts up*

    But very well, I don't mind elaborating. I speculate that they arrived as part of the entourages of any of the visitors - particularly the nobles, which there are several in the inn. Even if they are too unrefined to serve as manservants, they could have been hired as coaches, stable boys (men?), or just a general helping hand.

    It is also possible they got in as part of a merchant's party. Candlekeep does have to let merchants in rather often, after all, to provide food and drink for the monks (and the Inn and it's guests, too), not to mention equipment for the guards and whatever scholar-related products they cannot produce themselves.

    A third possibility is that they were hired to work in Candlekeep by the monks themselves. A giant keep doesn't keep itself, you know, and Winthrop certainly doesn't clean the inn himself regardless of his experience with elven arses. And besides direct servants they need guard recruits, craftsmen and workers of both skilled and unskilled labour. Carpenters, masons, builders in general, animal keepers, cooks and I don't know what but running a place like Candlekeep takes a lot of people. Carbos and Shank could have posed as basically any of the unskilled labours or entry/apprentice level positions in order to have gotten a free pass in.
    doggy said:

    I wonder who would spend the gold raising those two guys.

    Especially since a "Speak With Dead" (or whatever the name is) spell would be much, much cheaper in addition to them not being able to lie when questioned about what had happened.
  • SharGuidesMyHandSharGuidesMyHand Member Posts: 2,580
    scriver said:



    A third possibility is that they were hired to work in Candlekeep by the monks themselves.

    This has always been what I figured. In fact, I imagined that they were working there as stableboys or something to that effect, possibly even before the bounty offer was passed around.

    Either way, Gorion does saying something to the effect that, "No matter how tight a net is, there's always one or two mosquitoes that manage to slip through" - so he acknowledges that it's possible for people to sneak into Candlekeep in some form or another.
Sign In or Register to comment.