4

Comments

• Tresset Member, Moderator Posts: 8,264

  November 2015

  An interesting idea... I personally wouldn't be opposed to it, but that means very little. The one you really need to convince is @Dee .

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 0

  November 2015

  The user and all related content has been deleted.

  2
• Tresset Member, Moderator Posts: 8,264

  November 2015 edited November 2015

  Shandyr said:

  Tresset said:

  An interesting idea... I personally wouldn't be opposed to it, but that means very little. The one you really need to convince is Dee .

  And for doing so you'd have to come up with very good points as to why the subforum "off topic" is not sufficient to talk about other games.

  That is probably very much true. Dee usually doesn't do things like this without very good reason.

  2
• [Deleted User] Posts: 0

  November 2015

  The user and all related content has been deleted.

  0
• Jalily Member Posts: 4,681

  November 2015

  I think the Off-Topic forum is sufficient. I understand the desire to make neat subcategories, but there are two reasons why I wouldn't do that here:
  
  1) Usability. The list of boards is long and unwieldy enough as it is. It's not just the sidebar but the fact that moderators, especially of the non-English boards, have to scroll through the entire lineup every time they move a topic. There should be a good reason for adding more.
  
  2) It sets a precedent for creating even more off-topic boards and boards for non-Beamdog games, taking the focus away from the main purpose of this site. This is also why there are no boards dedicated to the original IE games, although discussion of them is allowed in the corresponding EE sections.

  7
• Dee Member Posts: 10,447

  November 2015

  Pretty much what @Jalily said. We won't discourage people from discussing other developers' games, but generally speaking it's a poor business model to encourage it in an official capacity.

  4