Dark Dreams of Furiae - a new module for NWN:EE! Buy now
Which weapon in BG2EE is the best for the thief's backstab?
Dagger of the star +5 seems like a good choice because of the chance to get a second backstab though the small damage is a drawback.
I was considering the staff of the ram +6 though I am not sure if the +12 crushing and +1d4 piercing are multiplied or added.