Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Categories

Neverwinter Nights: Enhanced Edition has been released! Visit nwn.beamdog.com to make an order. NWN:EE FAQ is available.
Soundtracks for BG:EE, SoD, BG2:EE, IWD:EE, PST:EE are now available in the Beamdog store.
Attention, new and old users! Please read the new rules of conduct for the forums, and we hope you enjoy your stay!

Demographics Poll: What is your sex/gender?

13»

Comments

  • ArdanisArdanis Member, Developer Posts: 1,303
  • Balrog99Balrog99 Member Posts: 3,370
    Ardanis said:

    According to a Gallup poll, a majority of people overall would prefer that transgender people should use the bathrooms corresponding to their sex at birth, but a majority of women specifically believe the opposite. 52% of women polled supported transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity; only 40% supported transgender people using bathrooms based on biological sex.

    Wonder if I'll get away entering a women's bath and claiming I'm genderfluid and feeling like a woman today :blush:

    It probably wouldn't be as great as great as you think anyway...

    semiticgod
  • UnderstandMouseMagicUnderstandMouseMagic Member Posts: 2,138

    @UnderstandMouseMagic: The women's preference you cite is not supported by data. According to a Gallup poll, a majority of people overall would prefer that transgender people should use the bathrooms corresponding to their sex at birth, but a majority of women specifically believe the opposite. 52% of women polled supported transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity; only 40% supported transgender people using bathrooms based on biological sex.

    Which position is correct is a more complicated issue, but as far as "women's preference" goes, a majority of women support transgender people choosing which bathroom they wish to use.

    I'm guessing this is because there's a strong political difference between Republicans and Democrats, and Democrats skew female while Republicans skew male: Republicans favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their sex at birth 71% to 25%, while Democrats favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity 63% to 29%.


    The poll you link to was based in America.

    But anyway, 40% of the women in the survey don't agree with transwomen using female bathrooms. If I understand it rightly, they think it should be based on biological sex? Which, if it's representative of the population as a whole, is a darn sight more women than transwomen.
    So why should they have their preference overided by a minority?

    Ardanis
  • SkatanSkatan Member Posts: 3,629

    @UnderstandMouseMagic: The women's preference you cite is not supported by data. According to a Gallup poll, a majority of people overall would prefer that transgender people should use the bathrooms corresponding to their sex at birth, but a majority of women specifically believe the opposite. 52% of women polled supported transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity; only 40% supported transgender people using bathrooms based on biological sex.

    Which position is correct is a more complicated issue, but as far as "women's preference" goes, a majority of women support transgender people choosing which bathroom they wish to use.

    I'm guessing this is because there's a strong political difference between Republicans and Democrats, and Democrats skew female while Republicans skew male: Republicans favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their sex at birth 71% to 25%, while Democrats favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity 63% to 29%.


    The poll you link to was based in America.

    But anyway, 40% of the women in the survey don't agree with transwomen using female bathrooms. If I understand it rightly, they think it should be based on biological sex? Which, if it's representative of the population as a whole, is a darn sight more women than transwomen.
    So why should they have their preference overided by a minority?

    Because in a democracy, the majority decides (kinda). In your country the majority might be against and perhaps that will be different there, if the topic is even raised.

    The notion that males would dress up as women and pretend to be female just to look at women washing their hands (it's not like they can push themselves into the actual booths where you do your thing.. ) in a female only bathroom is so immensely stupid and unfounded I am baffled by its sheer existance.

    GenderNihilismGirdle
  • QuickbladeQuickblade Member Posts: 665
    edited January 11
    Skatan said:

    @UnderstandMouseMagic: The women's preference you cite is not supported by data. According to a Gallup poll, a majority of people overall would prefer that transgender people should use the bathrooms corresponding to their sex at birth, but a majority of women specifically believe the opposite. 52% of women polled supported transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity; only 40% supported transgender people using bathrooms based on biological sex.

    Which position is correct is a more complicated issue, but as far as "women's preference" goes, a majority of women support transgender people choosing which bathroom they wish to use.

    I'm guessing this is because there's a strong political difference between Republicans and Democrats, and Democrats skew female while Republicans skew male: Republicans favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their sex at birth 71% to 25%, while Democrats favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity 63% to 29%.


    The poll you link to was based in America.

    But anyway, 40% of the women in the survey don't agree with transwomen using female bathrooms. If I understand it rightly, they think it should be based on biological sex? Which, if it's representative of the population as a whole, is a darn sight more women than transwomen.
    So why should they have their preference overided by a minority?

    Because in a democracy, the majority decides (kinda). In your country the majority might be against and perhaps that will be different there, if the topic is even raised.

    The notion that males would dress up as women and pretend to be female just to look at women washing their hands (it's not like they can push themselves into the actual booths where you do your thing.. ) in a female only bathroom is so immensely stupid and unfounded I am baffled by its sheer existance.
    Well, most bathroom stalls I'm familiar with, you could crawl under or climb over the walls unless you were a rather large man.

    Edit-At least mens' bathrooms. I'm not going to say I've NEVER been in a women's bathroom (once, late at night, in an old and empty building (because late at night) and the womens' bathroom was the one on that floor (old building), and I was curious), but I suspect there's no difference in modern bathroom stall design between men's and women's.

  • lroumenlroumen Member Posts: 1,644
    edited January 11
    You mean where you live the men's rooms do not have mythical golden tiles, scented perfumes, soft velvet covers on the seats, a well dressed attendant called Jeeves who is handing out tiny preheated towels, a make up specialist, an inspirational coach to make positive statements on shapes and figures, and a personal hygiene dispenser?

    GenderNihilismGirdlelolienThacoBell
  • SkatanSkatan Member Posts: 3,629

    Skatan said:

    @UnderstandMouseMagic: The women's preference you cite is not supported by data. According to a Gallup poll, a majority of people overall would prefer that transgender people should use the bathrooms corresponding to their sex at birth, but a majority of women specifically believe the opposite. 52% of women polled supported transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity; only 40% supported transgender people using bathrooms based on biological sex.

    Which position is correct is a more complicated issue, but as far as "women's preference" goes, a majority of women support transgender people choosing which bathroom they wish to use.

    I'm guessing this is because there's a strong political difference between Republicans and Democrats, and Democrats skew female while Republicans skew male: Republicans favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their sex at birth 71% to 25%, while Democrats favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity 63% to 29%.


    The poll you link to was based in America.

    But anyway, 40% of the women in the survey don't agree with transwomen using female bathrooms. If I understand it rightly, they think it should be based on biological sex? Which, if it's representative of the population as a whole, is a darn sight more women than transwomen.
    So why should they have their preference overided by a minority?

    Because in a democracy, the majority decides (kinda). In your country the majority might be against and perhaps that will be different there, if the topic is even raised.

    The notion that males would dress up as women and pretend to be female just to look at women washing their hands (it's not like they can push themselves into the actual booths where you do your thing.. ) in a female only bathroom is so immensely stupid and unfounded I am baffled by its sheer existance.
    Well, most bathroom stalls I'm familiar with, you could crawl under or climb over the walls unless you were a rather large man.

    Edit-At least mens' bathrooms. I'm not going to say I've NEVER been in a women's bathroom (once, late at night, in an old and empty building (because late at night) and the womens' bathroom was the one on that floor (old building), and I was curious), but I suspect there's no difference in modern bathroom stall design between men's and women's.
    .. and you think these men dressing up as women to con their way into womens' bathrooms are going to squeeze themselves in under the door to a toilet booth to peek at women doing the dirty? If any male is that intent on preying on women, they can just open the door to the bathroom and do it anyways. This is just a unfounded argument, inflating a hypothetical action that's not grounded in anything tangible.

    GenderNihilismGirdleThacoBell
  • semiticgodsemiticgod Member, Moderator Posts: 11,292
    The fact that even now, long after this first became an issue of public debate, there are no examples of transgender people using the women's bathroom to hurt women, despite the fact that most places have no laws banning MTF transgender people from these places, makes it fairly obvious that this fear isn't grounded in reality. You'd think that a debate this massive would be about a string of serious crimes, but the fact is, all the fears about sinister transgender people committing crimes in women's bathrooms are hypothetical fantasies.

    It's one of those "What if X happens?" debates where X doesn't actually happen.

    Even if we were talking about real crimes, a law banning transgender people from women's bathrooms would be unenforceable. Even cis-gender men can pass as women by changing their appearance. To prevent this hypothetical scenario, you'd literally need either DNA tests, inspectors, or video camera inside actual toilet bowls to detect hidden males or MTF transgender folks.

    GenderNihilismGirdleThacoBell
  • Balrog99Balrog99 Member Posts: 3,370

    The fact that even now, long after this first became an issue of public debate, there are no examples of transgender people using the women's bathroom to hurt women, despite the fact that most places have no laws banning MTF transgender people from these places, makes it fairly obvious that this fear isn't grounded in reality. You'd think that a debate this massive would be about a string of serious crimes, but the fact is, all the fears about sinister transgender people committing crimes in women's bathrooms are hypothetical fantasies.

    It's one of those "What if X happens?" debates where X doesn't actually happen.

    Even if we were talking about real crimes, a law banning transgender people from women's bathrooms would be unenforceable. Even cis-gender men can pass as women by changing their appearance. To prevent this hypothetical scenario, you'd literally need either DNA tests, inspectors, or video camera inside actual toilet bowls to detect hidden males or MTF transgender folks.

    Isn't that what the FBI does?

    Female Body Inspector - an old joke that all the juvenile boys used to guffaw at back when I was in grade school...

  • SilverstarSilverstar Member Posts: 2,189
    Isn't whether or not it's an unfounded fear besides the point? People already feel vulnerable and exposed when using the bathroom. Especially so when it's a public one. It makes sense to cling to whatever sense of comfort, privacy and security there is.

    This isn't exactly an issue with an easy resolution. If it was, someone would've come up with it by now.

    UnderstandMouseMagicThacoBell
  • QuickbladeQuickblade Member Posts: 665
    Skatan said:

    Skatan said:

    @UnderstandMouseMagic: The women's preference you cite is not supported by data. According to a Gallup poll, a majority of people overall would prefer that transgender people should use the bathrooms corresponding to their sex at birth, but a majority of women specifically believe the opposite. 52% of women polled supported transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity; only 40% supported transgender people using bathrooms based on biological sex.

    Which position is correct is a more complicated issue, but as far as "women's preference" goes, a majority of women support transgender people choosing which bathroom they wish to use.

    I'm guessing this is because there's a strong political difference between Republicans and Democrats, and Democrats skew female while Republicans skew male: Republicans favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their sex at birth 71% to 25%, while Democrats favor transgender people using bathrooms based on their gender identity 63% to 29%.


    The poll you link to was based in America.

    But anyway, 40% of the women in the survey don't agree with transwomen using female bathrooms. If I understand it rightly, they think it should be based on biological sex? Which, if it's representative of the population as a whole, is a darn sight more women than transwomen.
    So why should they have their preference overided by a minority?

    Because in a democracy, the majority decides (kinda). In your country the majority might be against and perhaps that will be different there, if the topic is even raised.

    The notion that males would dress up as women and pretend to be female just to look at women washing their hands (it's not like they can push themselves into the actual booths where you do your thing.. ) in a female only bathroom is so immensely stupid and unfounded I am baffled by its sheer existance.
    Well, most bathroom stalls I'm familiar with, you could crawl under or climb over the walls unless you were a rather large man.

    Edit-At least mens' bathrooms. I'm not going to say I've NEVER been in a women's bathroom (once, late at night, in an old and empty building (because late at night) and the womens' bathroom was the one on that floor (old building), and I was curious), but I suspect there's no difference in modern bathroom stall design between men's and women's.
    .. and you think these men dressing up as women to con their way into womens' bathrooms are going to squeeze themselves in under the door to a toilet booth to peek at women doing the dirty? If any male is that intent on preying on women, they can just open the door to the bathroom and do it anyways. This is just a unfounded argument, inflating a hypothetical action that's not grounded in anything tangible.
    No, I don't. I'm on the transgender side. Or at least the "who cares who uses which bathroom" since I am neither trans nor up in arms about them wanting to use the bathroom they want to use.

    semiticgod
  • UnderstandMouseMagicUnderstandMouseMagic Member Posts: 2,138

    The fact that even now, long after this first became an issue of public debate, there are no examples of transgender people using the women's bathroom to hurt women, despite the fact that most places have no laws banning MTF transgender people from these places, makes it fairly obvious that this fear isn't grounded in reality. You'd think that a debate this massive would be about a string of serious crimes, but the fact is, all the fears about sinister transgender people committing crimes in women's bathrooms are hypothetical fantasies.

    It's one of those "What if X happens?" debates where X doesn't actually happen.

    Even if we were talking about real crimes, a law banning transgender people from women's bathrooms would be unenforceable. Even cis-gender men can pass as women by changing their appearance. To prevent this hypothetical scenario, you'd literally need either DNA tests, inspectors, or video camera inside actual toilet bowls to detect hidden males or MTF transgender folks.



    Well they have managed to commit crimes in women's prisons.

    https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/sep/09/sexual-assaults-in-womens-prison-reignite-debate-over-transgender-inmates-karen-white

    An interesting fact from this article is this which I wasn't aware of;

    “Almost half of trans women prisoners are sex offenders,”

    Balrog99Ardanis
  • semiticgodsemiticgod Member, Moderator Posts: 11,292
    Interesting. To be fair, though, it's not really relevant to the bathroom debate.

  • semiticgodsemiticgod Member, Moderator Posts: 11,292

    Interesting. To be fair, though, it's not really relevant to the bathroom debate.

    Erm sorry what?

    How is it not relevent to take into account that a considerable percentage of men who claim to be, or are accepted as transexual women, are sex offenders?
    1. First, this statement is groundless, even including your previous citation. Your citation claimed that a large proportion of transgender women criminals committed sexual crimes. This does not establish that a "considerable percentage" of transgender women overall are criminals, whether sexual or otherwise.

    Put it this way: most female criminals (and I'm not talking about transgender women here; this is a very old statistic) commit property crimes, as opposed to violent crimes. Does that establish that "many women commit property crimes?" No--it establishes that, of the women who do commit crimes, those crimes are disproportionately property crimes. In order to establish that "a considerable percentage of men who claim to be, or are accepted as transexual women, are sex offenders," you need a statistic on the percentage of transgender women who are sex offenders.

    2. In order for these crimes to be relevant to the bathroom debate, the crimes in question need to have been committed in bathrooms.

    As for the transgender issue in regards to prisons, I have to agree with the statement at the end of the article: if a transgender woman still has male genitalia and isn't even undergoing hormone treatment, transferring them to a women's prison is a very bad idea to say the least. In addition, I would also forbid any trans women from moving to women's prisons if they had committed any sexual offense against women.

    SkatanThacoBell
  • semiticgodsemiticgod Member, Moderator Posts: 11,292
    The reason I want to stress this distinction is because the bathroom issue and the ratio of sex crimes to non-sexual crimes among transgender female criminals aren't actually related to each other--the only commonality between them is the underlying assumption that "many 'transgender women' are actually male rapists using transgender identity as a disguise," and I'm very suspicious of that concept. The idea--and I'm referring to a much, much broader trend in the public debate; I'm not talking about this thread itself--seems more grounded in (1) disbelief that transgender identity is even genuine among transgender people and (2) the fear of deviant men, as opposed to (3) a statistically-proven trend that men are getting away with crimes by falsely claiming to be transgender.

    There was a South Park episode where Cartman falsely claimed transgender status for his own advantage, but that's the closest thing I can think of to an example of this actually happening. All of the other transgender folks I've known, both on this forum and in real life, have seemed pretty candid about their identity, and none of them have profited from it or used it to get away with anything.

    SkatanGenderNihilismGirdleThacoBell
  • UnderstandMouseMagicUnderstandMouseMagic Member Posts: 2,138

    Interesting. To be fair, though, it's not really relevant to the bathroom debate.

    Erm sorry what?

    How is it not relevent to take into account that a considerable percentage of men who claim to be, or are accepted as transexual women, are sex offenders?
    1. First, this statement is groundless, even including your previous citation. Your citation claimed that a large proportion of transgender women criminals committed sexual crimes. This does not establish that a "considerable percentage" of transgender women overall are criminals, whether sexual or otherwise.

    Put it this way: most female criminals (and I'm not talking about transgender women here; this is a very old statistic) commit property crimes, as opposed to violent crimes. Does that establish that "many women commit property crimes?" No--it establishes that, of the women who do commit crimes, those crimes are disproportionately property crimes. In order to establish that "a considerable percentage of men who claim to be, or are accepted as transexual women, are sex offenders," you need a statistic on the percentage of transgender women who are sex offenders.

    2. In order for these crimes to be relevant to the bathroom debate, the crimes in question need to have been committed in bathrooms.

    As for the transgender issue in regards to prisons, I have to agree with the statement at the end of the article: if a transgender woman still has male genitalia and isn't even undergoing hormone treatment, transferring them to a women's prison is a very bad idea to say the least. In addition, I would also forbid any trans women from moving to women's prisons if they had committed any sexual offense against women.

    With regards to point 1, I have already corrected the wording to make it clear it related to convicted men in prison who are claiming to be or who are transgender.

    Point 2.
    Sorry what? A sexual attack can only be compared to another sexual attack if it happens in the same type of location?

    And regards the last statement, I suggest the criterior " still has male genitalia and isn't even undergoing hormone treatment," to be the deciding rule for any transexual woman using women only spaces.
    Whereas at the momnt, we have an ongoing push for this to be accepted from any self presenting transexual.

    Now as that of course cannot be enforced, then I am not in favour of transexual presenting women being allowed to use women only facilities.

    semiticgodSilverstar
13»
Sign In or Register to comment.