Skip to content

If you dug a hole through the earth, where would you end up?

2

Comments

  • FinneousPJFinneousPJ Member Posts: 6,455
    @deltago Guess... or look up on the map?
  • iKrivetkoiKrivetko Member Posts: 934
    Heindrich said:

    @FinneousPJ‌
    Well spotted. :) I actually live near Oxford at the moment, but I move around quite a lot, so I thought London would better represent the UK as a whole.

    Bonus points for anyone who can guess what my hometown is. :)


    It's not a small obscure city, but not particularly well known outside Asia.
    I can hardly picture a "small obscure city" in China. As far as I know, there are hardly any cities that have sub .5 million population.
  • HeindrichHeindrich Member, Moderator Posts: 2,959
    @iKrivetko‌
    iKrivetko said:


    I can hardly picture a "small obscure city" in China. As far as I know, there are hardly any cities that have sub .5 million population.

    By "obscure", I meant unknown to the wider world. For example Xi'an is not as well known as Beijing, Shanghai and Hong Kong, but it does have some international renown because is the provincial capital of Shaanxi and associated with the Terracotta Army. In contrast, nearby Xianyang, also a city of over 5 million, is virtually unknown outside of China, even though it was technically the first capital of a united China.

    Technically the Terracotta Army is in the countryside, so "the Terracotta Army is in Xi'an" is not strictly true. It was built when Xianyang was China's capital, but it got associated with Xi'an because the latter was larger and more important at the time of the discovery.


    Staying in the same province, it is even less likely that anyone outside China will have heard of Baoji, a city of over 3 million. China simply has too many cities with million+ population. Even Chinese people don't know all of them.
  • rufus_hobartrufus_hobart Member Posts: 490

    image

    Missed it by that much...glub...glub...glub...
  • FinneousPJFinneousPJ Member Posts: 6,455
    Bonus question time!

    If you did jump into your hole, how long would it take to fall through the earth to the other side?
  • NimranNimran Member Posts: 4,875

    Bonus question time!

    If you did jump into your hole, how long would it take to fall through the earth to the other side?

    Until the earth's gravity let's us go...
  • deltagodeltago Member Posts: 7,811

    Heindrich Yes, it does, but you don't magically stop in the middle after being accelerated by the pull ;)

    Yes you would stop dead centre or even before. For there is no longer an up or down at that point and you will be pulled to either side of the tunnel.
  • wubblewubble Member Posts: 3,156
    I'm fairly certain a tunnel through the core of the earth would either collapse in on itself immediately or it could cause some instability.
  • TJ_HookerTJ_Hooker Member Posts: 2,438
    edited December 2014
    deltago said:

    Heindrich Yes, it does, but you don't magically stop in the middle after being accelerated by the pull ;)

    Yes you would stop dead centre or even before. For there is no longer an up or down at that point and you will be pulled to either side of the tunnel.
    Err, I don't think so. Here's what I think would happen:

    Let's suppose for a moment that the earth is a perfect sphere, and the tunnel in question is dug directly through the center of the earth. Let's also neglect drag. The moment you fall into the tunnel , you would begin accelerating. You would continue to accelerate all the way until the moment you pass through the center. After that moment, you will begin to decelerate (but will continue moving in the same direction). You will reach zero velocity the moment you reach the end of the tunnel on the opposite side of the earth, at which point the whole process reverses itself. You oscillate between the 2 ends of the tunnel.

    If we add back drag, a similar thing would happen, but you wouldn't make it all the way to the other end, and each trip through the earth you would make it less distance than before. In other words, you oscillations would be damped.

    Edit: http://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/earth/geophysics/question373.htm
  • FinneousPJFinneousPJ Member Posts: 6,455
    @TJ_Hooker Is right and the linked spoiled it.

    If someone wants to still try don't open the link!
  • FinneousPJFinneousPJ Member Posts: 6,455
    @CrevsDaak @TJ_Hooker He's equating work with energy, which is fine.

    However - as @Musigny also pointed out - your first mistake @CrevsDaak is assuming constant acceleration. The acceleration is 10 ms^-2 only at the start, and decreases as we near the center. Also, in your final calculation for time, you're also assuming constant velocity, which isn't true. The velocity is only "endSpeed" at the center, and thus you cannot simply solve for time from that.
  • ShikaoShikao Member Posts: 376
    Whether I check hometown or current place of living I end up in sea south of Middle-earth New Zeland.

    image
  • AnduinAnduin Member Posts: 5,745
    The answer is Australia. Always.

    Dislike the idea that I was lied to as a child and in fact the answer is South of New Zealand, in deep, deep water.
  • CrevsDaakCrevsDaak Member Posts: 7,155

    However - as Musigny also pointed out - your first mistake CrevsDaak is assuming constant acceleration. The acceleration is 10 ms^-2 only at the start, and decreases as we near the center. Also, in your final calculation for time, you're also assuming constant velocity, which isn't true. The velocity is only "endSpeed" at the center, and thus you cannot simply solve for time from that.

    Yeah, now I realize I've done this as if it was on simple situation (eg a ball falling from a 2m heigth to the ground) and done many other errors too (weird that my mathematical calculations are OK...)
    Musigny said:

    CrevsDaak said:

    constDrag = 10m/s^2 (let's round it for my brain's sake...)

    This is not a constant. Not even an approximate value in this case. :wink:
    Having learnt physics in spanish I've supposed drag was the acceleration of an object going in a free fall due gravity (usually ~9.80 on most places (with surface/0 heigth) save the ecuador line and the poles), but I forgot it also changes with the change of the heigth (probably because it was 4am, same reason why I forgot calculating the loss of acceleration because of the air's friction).
  • FinneousPJFinneousPJ Member Posts: 6,455
    @CrevsDaak‌ Friction (drag) is unknown, so just ignore it.
  • deltagodeltago Member Posts: 7,811
    Anduin said:

    The answer is Australia. Always.

    Dislike the idea that I was lied to as a child and in fact the answer is South of New Zealand, in deep, deep water.

    (I am sorry have to)

    Well since you were a child the tetonic plates moved a couple hundred miles so you weren't lied to at all.
  • KaltzorKaltzor Member Posts: 1,050
    Seems like a lot of people would be going for New Zealand...

    image
  • CrevsDaakCrevsDaak Member Posts: 7,155
    Anduin said:

    The answer is Australia. Always.

    Dislike the idea that I was lied to as a child and in fact the answer is South of New Zealand, in deep, deep water.

    Well, I was always told I would end up in China… But ignore those, they are just people that were never given this task at school (yeah, when I was in 2nd year I think we did this on geography class).
Sign In or Register to comment.