Favorite and least favorite class/kit
Lammas
Member Posts: 228
So we have those couple of fun topics like this and I thought this might be another interesting question to ask around here. I'm honestly not sure what I'll be seeing here. I especially wonder what people dislike the most, honestly
If you strongly favor dual / multiclass characters: honorable mentions are off course alright but let's try to keep the main event on the singles.
Worst (probably):
I've several kits I've never played with. Probably never will but damn if beast master doesn't sound like the personal worst experience for me. I know for sure that no matter how many hours I might have left with this game over lord knows how many years I'm never going to make one of those. 3 animal summoning spells, and they all come along a little too late and basically when they've lived their usefulness you've just a ranger who can't use any metal stuff left. Not that they'd be very useful in the first place since you get them all a little too late. Maybe I'm wrong and it's a total beast (pun intended) but I'm honestly never even going to touch that because rangers aren't really my thing to begin with either.
I wrote half a book on my favorite but I realized I need to make it smaller and unfortunately I've got some IRL interference right now to take my attention off of it for a while. I'll post that later but I wanted to get this out there to see what people post.
If you strongly favor dual / multiclass characters: honorable mentions are off course alright but let's try to keep the main event on the singles.
Worst (probably):
I've several kits I've never played with. Probably never will but damn if beast master doesn't sound like the personal worst experience for me. I know for sure that no matter how many hours I might have left with this game over lord knows how many years I'm never going to make one of those. 3 animal summoning spells, and they all come along a little too late and basically when they've lived their usefulness you've just a ranger who can't use any metal stuff left. Not that they'd be very useful in the first place since you get them all a little too late. Maybe I'm wrong and it's a total beast (pun intended) but I'm honestly never even going to touch that because rangers aren't really my thing to begin with either.
I wrote half a book on my favorite but I realized I need to make it smaller and unfortunately I've got some IRL interference right now to take my attention off of it for a while. I'll post that later but I wanted to get this out there to see what people post.
6
Comments
Vanilla BG: F/M/T and Blade are my two favorites. They are basically different flavors of the same class. Being a little bit of everything. I prefer multiclasses to single (I am addicted to constant levelups), but the flavor of the bard class is a whole bunch of fun too.
Mod added: Herald (fighter/bard) A multiclass kit that gives the bard better figthing ability and a couple of thief skills at the cost of some spellcasting.
Meistersinger (bard kit) a druidic bard. Druids spells are my favorite and getting a bard that can cast druid spells is not only fun, but very powerful. Its also worth noting that these kits get sorceroor style spellcasting with their own unique lists.
For the worst class, I would have to say the Monk.
They're still really lame in BG1. Their main feature is to get special low-level versions of the Animal Summoning spells, but that doesn't matter in BG1 because they can't even start casting spells until so late in the game.
My favorite kit for BG1 is the Invoker. Being able to cast multiple -4 save Webs on a group of creatures and then cast multiple -2 save Fireballs on the paralyzed creatures is so great. I think I like Dynaheir more than Edwin now.
Last favourite: Monk (whether soloing or partying).
I always enjoyd having a bard in my party and I generally always have had Haer'Dalis in my party in BG2. I often thought about playing a bard in my (bi)annual playthroughs and I finally decided to give it a shot now that I bought EE. Holy crap I'm having fun. I haven't even started SOD once because I always end up making a new one with different party members just trying to learn the ins and outs of it and deciding what I want it to wield in BG1 and going into SOD and BG2 eventually. I'm currently on my 4th run back to back, one of them my first ever solo run of the game I can't believe I didn't go down this road years earlier.
And I just now realized I can now dual-wield AND use ranged these days which is going to make this even better!
https://forums.beamdog.com/discussion/66428/your-signature-character-class/p1
https://forums.beamdog.com/discussion/37566/anyone-have-characters-they-gravitate-toward/p1
Fav: Druid (any kit)
Least fav: Berserker (too easy to play to my taste)
Least fav is... Wild Mage. Ok, kill me, but i'm a square and i can't accept that if i'm doing everything right the bad luck can fuck up everything. Even if i never played "no reload" i usually accept the consequences of wrong planning without reloading, and i can't stand that cows can kill everybody just because.
Don't misunderstand me, it's totally funny, but not if i play it myself
My least favourite is probably a vanilla fighter... Until they get HLAs the only thing they can do is right click an enemy to death, which is just so tedious (as Eldoth would say).
Least favourite: wild mage. I just can't stand this class. I find the randomness really annoying both in terms of game play and aesthetic. I don't enjoy having a great battle ruined by a surge, or all my gold disappearing - though I'll admit that seeing a pit fiend summoned in Beregost was entertaining. And I don't find the weird visuals and sound effects of the sillier surges (sillier surges - am I starting to sound like Baeloth?) appealing or amusing. While I love Beamdog for bringing us the blackguard, I confess to being disappointed at getting a wild mage for an NPC.
Worst: Berserker. Terribly designed, in no way resembling its namesake. Well, unless you count the fact that Enrage allows the player to shut their brain off and brute force their way through fights. Then it’s appropriate, I suppose.
1. Sorcerer (actually Paladin/Sorcerer, if it existed)
2. Fighter/Mage
3. Ranger/Cleric ("unfixed" one)
Least favourite:
Can't say yet, haven't tried many!
1) Skald/Bard: A force multiplier for basically everything else in the game.
2) Cleric/Mage: One of the most flexible supportive class combos in the game
3) Shaman: Every possible spell/effect you might want that Cleric/Mage doesn't have.
Least favorite: Jester. Takes everything positive I like about standard Bards and turns it into a save-or-suck.
I'm pleasantly surprised to see no hate for the Shapeshifter or the Wizard slayer in this thread; they used to be the magnets for "worst class ever" debates.
Least favorite would have to be the wild mage, solely because they can wipe away hard-earned gold in the blink of an eye.