Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Categories

Dark Dreams of Furiae - a new module for NWN:EE! Buy now
Attention, new and old users! Please read the new rules of conduct for the forums, and we hope you enjoy your stay!

There is no excuse this time for not upgrading the models and textures in the game.

24567

Comments

  • semiticgodsemiticgod Member, Moderator Posts: 14,186
    I do think it's a shame that we're not getting more advanced graphics, and I definitely am going to use a mod to improve them. But it's true--creating new meshes and new textures for a game as massive as NWN would be extremely expensive. Beamdog's specialty is improving source code, and that's what they've chosen to focus on for NWN:EE.

    BelleSorciere[Deleted User]mf2112mlnevese
  • InflatableFriendInflatableFriend Member Posts: 57
    Perhaps it'd help to quantify exactly what you think would make a worthwhile update to graphics quality?

    I know I've got a few recent indie games kicking around that compare on fidelity. NWN:EE would be equal to more if you ramped up NWN's brightness and got the SSAO filter fully functional (it's in already, just weak).

    There will be more visual tweaks to come, but what exactly is it you feel is needed?

    [Deleted User]
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 0
    edited November 2017
    The user and all related content has been deleted.

  • 1varangian1varangian Member Posts: 356
    edited November 2017
    NWN 1 is a one of its kind game that sold very well in spite of the criticized single player campaign.

    If any game deserves a complete remake, it's this one. The limitless content creation, modding and PW capability doesn't even have any competition out there.

    The graphics are the only thing about NWN that doesn't work today. Everything else is still good. And the visuals only need to be good enough to be immersive. The Witcher 1 or NWN 2 standards. 10 years old instead of 15 years old.

    I don't think there's any point in redoing the original OC. But.. If there would be a new official campaign with updated visuals and maybe full party support for a proper D&D party I'd be very happy to throw in 50€ for that. And then after finishing the SP campaign play on PW's with the same updated visuals until the end of time.


    [Deleted User]BelgarathMTHSymphonyAvenger_teambg
  • WarChiefZekeWarChiefZeke Member Posts: 2,024
    edited November 2017
    I am personally willing to accept no total graphic overhaul in exchange for more premium modules or expansions to please single players (like myself) and updates to the toolset and source code to please modders and the PW community (like myself) and hopefully get some upgrades in the future by modders like we have for other games. As is stands i'm gonna patiently wait for the features to roll out before buying.

    But I still think they could use crowdfunding if they have to because I think people would be very enthusiastic about that.

    BelgarathMTHcherryzero
  • ReibornReiborn Member Posts: 156
    there are plenty of graphic enhancements to the original game I'm sure they can implement some with EE.

    [Deleted User]
  • The user and all related content has been deleted.

    Reiborn
  • IndyWendieGoIndyWendieGo Member Posts: 62
    Shandaxx said:

    there are plenty of graphic enhancements to the original game I'm sure they can implement some with EE.

    Actually this makes me curious. Is there an overview somewhere? A list of "all" (as in "many") mods for visual improvements? And would such mods be compatible with NWN:EE?
    In theory they should be compatible, but I'm not 100% sure. Here's a video with some relevant haks from 1.69. Everything is linked in the description.

    [Deleted User]
  • InflatableFriendInflatableFriend Member Posts: 57
    I wouldn't just leave your hope with the modders.

    It'll be the changes that Beamdog make to the fundamentals of the engine that allow people to make more modern looking content.

    Without having a really in depth poke (hopefully I'll be able too next week) it's hard to say what exactly the limits of the engine are currently compared to what they were. Given what's been hinted at and the potential of the new shaders I don't see NWN2 as being that much of a leap for new content. Sadly there's no quick and simple way of bringing the old content to that sort of standard, it'd mean rebuilding every asset.

    Maybe think of what exists now as the NWN:EE Legacy content. It'll benefit from overall engine tweaks, better AA, shading tweaks, AO, modern system compatibility plus bugfixes, tweaks and more players. Future modules and content packs from Beamdog, modders or other studios could be made to more modern standards (and if there was a simple .fbx workflow then you could buy content easily from many 3rd party vendors).

    [Deleted User]WarChiefZekemlnevese
  • CvijetaCvijeta Member Posts: 394
    I actually like the graphics. Don't touch the graphics, no, no!

    BaratanSylvius_the_MadDerpCity
  • smeagolheartsmeagolheart Member Posts: 7,638
    Without a graphics update, and requiring people to buy the deluxe version just to get the premium modules, I'm not seeing much difference over the GOG version here.

    What's enhanced about it.

    [Deleted User]
  • BelleSorciereBelleSorciere Member Posts: 2,095

    Without a graphics update, and requiring people to buy the deluxe version just to get the premium modules, I'm not seeing much difference over the GOG version here.

    What's enhanced about it.

    That it'll work on most modern machines.

    ThacoBellBelgarathMTHSylvius_the_Mad
  • tbone1tbone1 Member Posts: 1,995
    I dunno, I’ve often found “time” and “money” to be pretty damn good reasons for a lot of things.

    BelgarathMTH
  • XerahXerah Member Posts: 2
    Shandaxx said:

    @BelleSorciere

    I think you are being very aggressive here. Would you please tone down your aggression a bit?

    Apparently, reason and objective analysis based what we know is considered aggressive. Go figure, I guess.

    NWN isn't the game you play if you really care about visuals. Never was. Never will be.

    BelleSorciereBelgarathMTH
  • smeagolheartsmeagolheart Member Posts: 7,638
    bob_veng said:

    What's enhanced about it.

    here are the improvements https://www.beamdog.com/files/nwnee_release_notes.pdf

    looks like they've made a very nice patch for the original game. i wouldn't really call this a new edition, rather a new version
    Sounds like a new business model - Pay to patch.

    [Deleted User]WarChiefZekebob_veng
  • ArctodusArctodus Member Posts: 996
    @smeagolheart Well, Beamdog is not the original game creator. You expect them to delve into the source code, patch the game for the first time in years, offer server services and continued maintenance for free ?

    BelgarathMTHbob_vengAvenger_teambg
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 0
    edited November 2017
    The user and all related content has been deleted.

    ThacoBellCablefishmodestvolta
  • smeagolheartsmeagolheart Member Posts: 7,638
    edited November 2017
    Irrc aren't like the character skins png (or similar I recall using gimp). How hard would it be to make those higher definition? You don't even have to mess with the meshes just add better textures.

    Same for the tilesets.

    cherryzero
  • AncarionAncarion Member Posts: 134
    NWN uses plt files for dynamic creature textures, which have 10 layers corresponding to skin, hair, metal, etc. This makes for an easy way to customize colors, but limits things in the sense that there can only be one solid color for each layer. In the past, custom content pioneers like BigfootNZ worked at ways to improve how these plt textures worked, but there's just no way to get the variation of tones and colors that can be achieved with other texture formats.

    [Deleted User]IndyWendieGoPokotaThacoBell
  • EbonstarEbonstar Member Posts: 105
    Raduziel said:

    They can improve the game appearance without changing the graphics.

    One way to do so is using the skins and tilesets and placeables from Project Q and CEP.

    Adding more heads to character creation would improve the way the game looks without burdening the budget.

    They can add a sub-race system, a helluva improvement compared to the vanilla NWN without major problems.

    And the valse goes on.

    they can only tweak and improve that which they own and have license too.

    mlnevesePokota
  • cherryzerocherryzero Member Posts: 129
    Cablefish said:



    Sounds like a new business model - Pay to patch.

    The thing is though. I've been waiting for this patch since 2005 (or was it 2006 that 1.69 dropped?). I've had all of my most immersive roleplaying playing this game. Not because of the graphics but because this game made almost ANYTHING from tabletop RPG's possible.

    I didn't stop playing NWN because graphics changed got outdated. I stopped playing because a lot of players migrated to NWN2. That game in turn failed to live up to expectations and was worse than NWN1 in many ways. The release of NWN2 also meant support for the scripters, modders and builders who made dreams come true stopped. The shutdown of the Gamespy server finding tools then made it harder for new players to find all those beautiful gems people were playing online.

    Just a chance to breathe new life into the literally millions of hours the community have spent creating wonders on this platform is well worth the price. You just don't find that level of user created content anywhere anymore. And i've already paid the digital deluxe cost because of a that already. And i'm VERY sceptical of pre-orders in general. I'm paying to patch and i'd recommend all my friends to do the same!
    I played both NWN and NWN2. Both had thriving communities. The NWN community definitely quieted down after NWN2 took off. I remember, on the NWN forums there was a lot of NWN2 bashing about how much worse the sequel was, how ugly the graphics were and what a failure of a game it was...

    I pulled this from the web to make a point:

    "Reception of Neverwinter Nights 2 was generally favorable.[74][75] It placed number 6 on Amazon's video game pre-order list the week before its release,[77] and was a best-seller for several weeks afterwards.[78][79] It received GameSpot's "Best Story" award for 2006, beating out the reader's choice, The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion.[76] It was also nominated for a Golden Joystick Award for Best PC Game of 2006.[80] The editors of Computer Games Magazine presented Neverwinter Nights 2 with their 2006 "Best Writing" award, and it was a runner-up for their list of the year's top 10 computer games.[81]"

    Maybe the sequel failed to live up to your personal expectations because the aurora engine was more advanced thus more complicated to work with. Maybe your computer couldn't handle the updated graphics. Maybe you didn't like that they got rid of the 'dance of death.' I don't know. Each to their own. Personally I enjoyed both games and didn't need a high end computer to run either.

    My reason for bringing it up is this, there seems to be this sort of defacto position some people took on the original NWN forums that is being regurgitated here that NWN2 was a failure and its better graphics didn't make a difference then and won't now.

    This is a bad argument because it is a false one. The game was fairly successful and the graphics upgrade was well received both critically and by a large section of the community.

    Don't get me wrong, I'm just saying this particular argument isn't a good one. Beamdog saying they just don't have the recourses to do a graphics overhaul is a legitimate argument and one I think should be respected by the community. We're all here presumably because we like Beamdog and how they are breathing life into these old games.

    Conversely I think it is both legitimate and productive for potential customers to express their desire to see updated graphics. If anything at least it gives Beamdog a sense of what their customer base is willing to pay for. Maybe it only turns out to be a small portion of the base, maybe it turns out to be a large one. If it's a large one maybe they can make money by releasing DLC that addresses it.

    I don't know. It's really probably too early for anyone to know. But if the topic is going to be debated it should be debated honestly.

    modestvolta
  • 1varangian1varangian Member Posts: 356
    edited November 2017
    acidchalk said:

    You people still don't get it. Each piece of armor is made up of 2 fists 2 forearms 2 biceps 2 shoulders a neck a chest a pelvis a belt 2 thighs 2 shins and two feet. Now multiply that by every single type of armor in the game. Each type of armor has several different meshes and skins per individual body part. When i say a metric ass ton of work i am very much understating it. When i got around to making odd shaped custom races back in the day i was confronted by a massive amount of incredibly mind numbing, tedious work in order to shape each existing piece into the shape of my odd shaped pc race so that he could wear all of the vanilla armor. Just trust me it's a retarded amount of work that would cost a retarded amount of time and money.

    So change the system so that an upgraded armor is one fixed piece.

    I don't care about that level of customization since whatever you do, it will still look like 2002.

    Post edited by 1varangian on
Sign In or Register to comment.